Who else thinks a prime RJJ beats the whole LHW division

Based on the fact that Hill is widely considered one of the top 10 LHW's in history.
The better question should be, who have any of them beaten to be considered better
than Hill, let alone Jones. I'm a big fan of Ward and Kovalev, but lets be serious.

 

Why should I even bother debating you?

Nobody has mentioned anything about Foster or Spinks, and why are you only focusing on the low level guys he beat??

Roy also looked good against Hopkins, Toney, Malinga, Sosa, Griffin, Hill, R Johnson, Woods and Ruiz etc.

You dig yourself the biggest hole without even realising it. You say he had a pathetic chin, yet he spent years at LHW when he could have just stayed at SMW for the majority of his career. So why does he not credit for having fought naturally bigger guys whilst possessing a pathetic chin?

No, Ruiz wasn't a great HW like Mike, but he was still a tough, top 5-10 HW of his time.

Spinks was a true ATG. And whilst he deserves huge credit for having a run at HW, you have to note that he was younger than Roy, he'd had less fights, and he was naturally bigger. Roy started out at MW, and even had a few fights as a JMW.

It's a complete myth that Roy didn't chase down the biggest fights of his time. It's a myth that I have repeatedly exposed. I have given you links, excerpts and interviews, with fighters, managers, trainers and TV execs etc. But being the ignorant guy that you are, you don't want to acknowledge them.

 

You have said he would achieve the feat of beating Ward, Kovalev, Stevenson, Beterbiev... Based on what? Who's he beat comparable to those 4? Four names please? I don't think those 4 are unbeatable & nor do i think it's a given they all beat RJJ. What i do find irritating is suggesting Hill runs through today's division..

Dariusz out boxed him. Now tell me why those 4 can't? AB's a little green sure.. Ward? Kovalev? Stevenson?

 

I just liked my wife.

 

Bit late now..

 

You only just noticed? Page 6...

 

Rita sue & bob too.. Get on it serge with my pleasure lol

 

I just liked my self with a carrot.

 

Are you for real??

Seriously??

Where I have I said he would have ran through the division?

How many times do you need it explaining it to you??

I never said that. However, I do think he'd be favoured over everyone today. Now if you actually read what what I've wrote instead of saying you can't be arsed, you'd realise how my opinions have been formed. I have given you specific examples, and I've given you some an*logies to consider. I have also listed what I think are Roy's top 5 wins at the weight.

If you're not prepared to read my posts and you don't want an objective debate, then don't quote me again.

 

No i acknowledged that part. I just want you to state who were the best fighters in his era. For the record..

Top 3 RJJ era LHWs?

 

Sure.

It was a perfect shot.

Pretty much anybody can get taken out with a perfect shot.

The question is: Would they have had the opportunity to have landed it?