Who gave Margo a bigger beat down?

In the magical fantasy world of Pacland.................

Why do you guys talk about fights like I haven't seen it?

Not true at all. Was a quite competitive fight until at least round 8

 

Shane just outboxed Margarito. Aint nothing you can do about that.

Pacquiao giving him chances to win is down to his own weaknesses

 

I have the feeling Pacquiao and Floyd see their fight like Jones and Hopkins did.

Something to go back to when they're both 40

 

yeah he outboxed margo who is denying that? but look at margo's performance in both fights and see which fight he was more focused, prepared and mentally ready.

 

Pac, but Mosleys shots were powerful enought to break Margaritos chin and drop him.

 

Manny i vote. Will definetly do more long term damage.

 

his swollen eye can be repaired, there is no repair from brain damage, I believe brain damage is permanent .

After shane finished with Margarito he didn't know where he was, a sign of a concussion.

The real difference here is Margarito could not stay awake to for the beating shane gave him.

 

Disagree, Margos head was clear for Pac, his head was mince after the dressing room fiscal for Mosley.

Imagine going into a fight having watched pads that were in your wraps being taken away by the commission. His mind would have been all over the place.

 

Tricky this one. You could eiher choose Shane because he could chop Margarito down to a stoppage, or Pac because he couldn't, so tattoed him over 12.

But since Shane beat a prime Margarito to past his best, my vote goes to him. That was savage and at no point as competitive as this one.

 

wouldn't criteria for a beating be knocking someone out? Not fracturing an orbital bone? Shane knocked out Margarito and Manny did not. I am not sure there is a question who gave the bigger beat down.

 

margarito is overrated he should not of been in the ring he looked like a zombie out there, his shoulders were slouched over he had slow hand and feet movement he looked more like an extra from a horror flick:think

 

I think it's obvious, you can't compare 12 round beating to Snane's fight

 

Shane took a page from His papa Hopkins in beating Margo. Pac never used the bluprint Shane left because its a cheating style. Hold and grab. It was the same cheating way Holyfield used in knocking out Tyson. On the other hand Pac carved up Margos face like a true Picasso. The finished result is like Margo beaten badly by some Gangsters in the streets. Thats how bad the beatdown he received from Pac. You must be a pac hater not to see that.

 

Mosley I would say put on a better performance, because he KO a guy who was considered to having an iron chin. Manny beat snot out of Marg but did not KO him. I really wish Pac would of fought Shane earlier instead of ducking him. Now Arum is looking at Shane as a potential opponent because 39 is creeping on him. Mosley has been a potential opponent but they didn't want to see his potential then.