Who had a Better Lightweight(135) Career, Juan Manuel Marquez or Juan Diaz?

Quote that post about me rating Hamed over Pac.

Find it and quote that post. That is utter BS. Or better yet go make another poll.

Point is 1 or 2 times doing something isn't a career. You're talking about head to head - Not someone's "career" - Two very different things.

 

And miss your next poll? What would I do for entertainment.

Facts are facts.

Besides, if I started using ignore on this forum there's would be like 5 threads for me to view total.

Plus while I love ribbing Farm for his inability to split the Klitschko gene, he does post some decent posts on non Klit or Void related subject matters.

 

diaz, if youre talking about his reign as lw, technically has better career than jmm. cause of course everybody knows jmm went to lw at age 35 yrs. and he is not a natural lw

but h2h, you know the answer....and i believe that jmm would have beaten the top fighters that jd had faced as a lw.

 

Asero, you're a good bloke and while I do rib you a bit, I like the passion of your fandom. I worked with a couple of Pinoy's with whom we enjoy many boxing debates and share in the joy of Manny's fights.

Well going by your defnition of a "career" - Manny at 126 has four times the legacy of his 140lbs campaign!

Generally speaking when I rank fighters at certain weights, it's based on achievement over a given length of time.

For example, I wouldn't put Duran on a welterweight, Jnr Middle, Middle or Super Middle list.

Lightweight I'd put him as one.

Let me give YOU a poll question: What is Manny's prime weight class?

 

probably diaz, cause jmm's prime weight class was at feather.

it does not hold much bearing though, cause jmm beat him.

 

Oohhh - That's a good question too now we're in 09.

135lbser of the decade...

The division certainly had fight of the decade with Corrales Castillo...

 

He has three more title defences than Tito of the belt he won.

Joppy at middle - 34 wins 3 losses

Tinidad - 3 wins 2 losses.