Who has fought the better fighter J.TAYLOR or CALZAGHI?

Oh yeah?atsch Tell me who the hell on Joe's record other than who I mentioned is worth talking about?:roll:

 

Nah, I'm no expert, but I've seen nearly all of Joe Calzaghe's fights so I've got a good idea who is best opposition are and it's disrespectful to imply Manfredo ranks highly

 

Also add, you shouldn't be allowed to discuss Jermain Taylor because your disdain for him is unreal.

 

Good point you just made, I agree. But Wright and Taylor fought to a draw.

 

atsch atsch this kind of post makes arguing seem ridiculous and makes calzaghe fans look bad

 

Why don't you expand on that, rather than posting laughing blue smilies?

 

There is no need to expand on that. You're posts are so biased and one sided that anyone with logic can see them. :nut

 

Find a quote from me saying he had A class skills, that was not the point.
As for performances in fights, i find your perspective dubious. Eubank was a very close fight, as was Reid, he looked less than stellar against Bika and i saw the Kessler fight as very close too, calzaghe edging it with his speed and movement. The same can be said of Wright's career, it's very easy to be critical. As i previously said i think Calzaghe has the better resume. When you start doing the little kiddy speak is when the problem arises.

 

Ah, the old rolling eye smilie

Clearly a more sound basis for an argument than the laughing blue smilie

You guys are killing me here

 

Maybe you should just kill yourself.

Where exactly do you have Calzaghe ranked in the ATG list?

Where do you rank Kessler, Pavlik, and Taylor on the P4P list?

Let's have it.

 

:good

 

Taylor isn't even a top 20, get that out of your head.

Pavlik is top 15 by default, soon enough he'll be disposed of.

Kessler is top 15 also.

In a H2H P4P list, Kessler is top 10, Pavlik and Taylor are not top 20, especially Taylor, that ****ing piece of garbage.

 

I think it's you that asked me this before, and I'm reluctant to place active fighters, but gut feeling is lower top 100 at the moment. Could easily change if he wins his last 2 fights in the style I expect

Kessler is above Taylor and Pavlik, no doubt

I expect this was the answer you were looking for, as its clearly bias on my part. But of course we'll see just how stupid I am now that Taylor has moved to SMW

 

are you being serious?calzaghe struggled with eubank,what fight di you watch,he demolished him,fair enough eubank was faded but it was still a dominating victory.

'little kiddy speak'? what the **** are you going on about mate?

 

Amsterdam and TFFP,

Kelly Pavlik and Jermain Taylor really, really sucks right?

And Kessler and Calzaghe is like, really, really good right?

Does that sum it up for you guys?