Who has the better resume since Pac JMM II?

nah, am not even wasting my time on kid's stuff like this.

hate all you want, Pac Knockouts all your heroes. Nothing can be fairer than that.

 

How in the world is David Diaz better than Juan Diaz or Joel Casamayor? Have u seen his record? It stinks. Oscar de le Hoya was not himself. I don't understand how anyone can possibly think that. I guess u haven't watched many of his fights. If he had been at 90% he would have wrecked Pacquiao. He would have destroyed him. I dont hate Pacquiao. I love him. He's great for the sport. I love watching his fights, but as of late Marquez has fought the better competition. You guys need to get off his jock. Seriously.

 

You degrade Juan Diaz then talk up David Diaz? What the **** is wrong with YOU?

For me, Pacquiao.

 

I want to hear an unbiased opinion from a sensible poster.

 

ODLH always have difficulty fighting southpaws...It MIGHT have a different outcome, a more competitive fight but no way he will wreck pacquiao...

 

i love it when guys say that hoya was shot while casamayor was "past-prime." you guys are funny. at least de la hoya did not go life and death against a crude brawler in katsidis.

dlh @ 147>casamayor @135 by far
d diaz @135 and hatton @140> j diaz 135.

this is pretty straightforward.

 

how about D. Diaz + OLDH > Casamayor
Hatton > J. Diaz

Or D. Diaz + OLDH > J. Diaz
Hatton > Casamayor

that seems like a fair assessment

 

Your case is weak, make a poll again if ever JMM beat PBF

 

i'll say an old casa was more game than an overrated Ricky Hatton.

 

definitely pac. he didn't even lose a round against dlh and hatton..

 

Jose Santa Cruz won about every round vs Casa, it was one of the clearest biggest robberies in modern boxing.

Juan Diaz deserved a UD loss to Campbell.

You can pick apart anybody's opponents, its very easy

 

yes dlh looked bad against forbes, sure. i am not trying to deny the fact that dlh was shot. my point is casamayor is also shot when jmm fought him.

you're making it seem that katsidis is the best thing since sliced bread. katsidis is a crude brawler who's fun to watch but will never be anything special. and that crude fighter was beating casamayor til he got careless and got caught with a strong punch. add to that, casamayor was coming off a gift decision over santa cruz and a year long layoff. dlh was coming off an ugly win over forbes and a loss against mayweather. you cant possible consider dlh shot while jmm gets a ton of respect for beating casa.

juan diaz lost to campbell and sd'd katsidis before taking on jmm. hatton lost to the best p4p fighter in pbf and was coming off a win over malignaggi, has never been beaten in 140 nand is the ring champ. david diaz is nobody, i totally agree.

again dlh @ 147 > casa @ 135
hatton @140+ d diaz at 135 > j diaz.

you have spotty arguements kid. you rave about casamayor having a belt while hatton held the same belt just on a different weight class. then you bring down hatton by saying he was almost knocked out by lazcano when casamayor was also almost knocked out by hatton.

if jmm beats pbf, then his three wins will be better than pac's three wins. but as of now, pac's wins are bigger than jmm's.

 

The *******s on this forum make me want to throw-up. :verysad

That said, Pacquiao overtook Marquez with the win over Hatton. Quality win, people will try and downgrade it all day but he destroyed a fighter who had beaten Kosta Tsyzu. It's not just that he beat him but the fashion in which he did it.

 

Besides who Pac and JMM beat, you also how to consider how they won. Even if you can argue that Casa and Juan Diaz are better names than Oscar, David Diaz and Hatton combined, it won't be by much. But Pac won every round against the three and he utterly annihilated all 3 opponents. While JMM's fights were much closer right around the time he knocked them out.