Who has the Greater Depth in their resume out of these Legends?

I have gone for De La Hoya as they are all top names on his resume.

 

he would get my vote

 

Oscar by a country mile. Just prime Floyd and prime Pacman are enough to obliterate Holyfield's resume.

You have to understand that post-prison Tyson is not prime Tyson.

Lennox fought all his best opponents past their primes, except for Vitali who was beating him up until the lucky cut.

 

Holyfield

 

its close between Evander and Lennox

Oscar is by far the worst. Lost or gifted in all of his big fights outside of Tito

Camacho was average and Chavez was washed up

 

DLH EASY! About 6 ATGs on his resume as well as the highest amount of PFP #1 fighters around the time he fought them:deal

 

Lewis takes this

resume depth is determined by BOTH WINS AND LOSSES

 

The Real Deal.

 

.........then how on earth is Lewis the one who takes it?

Lennox has a very good resume overall, but he's fourth out of four in this lineup for me.

 

if holmes, tyson and foreman had been in their prime i'd have voted for holyfield but since none of them were; oscar.

 

How would Lewis come out ahead?

DLH faced prime versions of Pacquiao, Mayweather, Mosley, and Trinidad. 4 HOFers, two of whom are usually rated as the top 2 fighters of the new millennium. He faced an ATG in Hopkins when he was rated at the top of the p4p rankings. He faced undefeated Quartey. He faced Whitaker when he was the lineal WW champ and still highly rated on the p4p rankings.

Holyfield faced Riddick Bowe 3x, Lewis 2x, Tyson 2x (post-prison, but still much better than the Tyson of 02' that Lewis faced). After a dozen pro fights, he faced Dwight Qawi. And fought him again a year later.

What did Lewis do to be ahead of them? Bringing up wins AND losses doesn't help Lewis's case, if anything, it weakens his case. He lost to Hasim Rahman and Oliver McCall. DLH lost to HOFers and ATGs.