who has the greater legacy at this piont, floyd or shane

I believe you.

 

Learn boxing, his lineal title came after beating Genaro Hernandez
who got the lineage from Nelson.

Shane had the IBF 135 title from Phillip Holiday with no unification at 135. Floyds 2 victories over Castillo at 135 destroys Mosley's overrated resume at that weight.

Both 6 titles but Floyd had 3 lineal and Mosley 2.

:hat

 

WHo they will fight is nothing compared to who they beat. Mayweather has beaten better fighters and more champion fighters then Mosley. Deal with it.

If Mosley wants to be like Mayweather, he needs to win a title at super middleweight.

 

Gregorio Vargas not Fernando.

 

I think he won the oscar fight, but all of the judges didn't.

Jr middleweight fight. Like I ****ing said.

Floyd Mayweather has 0 impressive welterweight wins.

 

http://boxrec.com/list_bouts.php?human_id=1208&cat=boxer

This guy? look at his opponents records, are you kidding?
This is a big win?

 

Mayweather cherrypicked his legacy away. Shane fought almost everybody. Including two ill-advised fights against Winky Wright.

 

They guy said that Floyd has 0 impressive welterweight wins and you went off on a tangent about oscar 154 and ricky hatton, nice way to avoid what he said

 

I said he was a world champion not the magnitude of the victory, and Mayweather pretty much shut him out in that fight.

 

Now youre exibiting foolishness. Anybody can see that Shane is undersized at even 154

Different people different sizes

Mosley has moved or skipped up through 4 divisions he and floyd are the exact same size now


I guess if Hatton wants to be as good as Pac he has to go up to HW ????

WTF use your damn head stick to boxrec christ

 

Who???

:rofl:rofl:rofl

 

yes. you come on like you are an expert on who is better and it turns out you havent even seen half the fights being disscussed. why not admit that there may be better qualified posters to judge these 2. you know, like someone who has seen all of their respective careers.

 

So by your reasoning. Pernell Whitaker really didnt beat Jose Luis Ramirez. He really did draw with Julio Cesar Chavez. :rofl

I mean the judges said he did! clown.

Hatton P4P 8. Victory over Luis Collazo for the WBA world welterweight title. Same guy that many said beat Mosleys next opponent Andre Berto.


Stop embarrassing yourself.

 

I've seen all of Mayweathers career. I've seen most of Molseys career, mostly just his fights at lightweight I havent seen.

1. Its clear that he didnt beat many champs at lightweight,.

2. He never attempted to unify anything.

 

The funny part about Floyds line of

"split decision dont count"


is that he said this to justify fighting ZAB after losing to Carlos Baldomir, the idiot never even realised that Baldomir won by UD

lol