Haye punches sharper Vitali punches heavier Different kinds of punching power, thus guys react differently to both.
Vitali was a massive massive puncher. One of the best punchers in heavyweight history. Prime Vitali only lost to Chris Byrd and Old Shot Lennox Lewis. I will take Prime Vitali over David Haye for sure.
Vitali is a hard puncher yet he couldn't knock out fat out of shape unmotivated glass chin Lennox Lewis. Yet Rahman and McCall did? Vitali is a i am bigger than you and I will throw punch after punch after to punch to TKO a blown up cruiserweight puncher.
Haye. Vitali could hit harder in a one-punch- competition, but in the ring, Haye hits harder, really harder, he puts everything under every overhand.
Vitali has a harder output in his prime. Haye relies on single shots much much more With harder output I mean, being able to use your power to KO an opponents. Vitali is extremely good with that, Haye swings extremely wild, lacks stamina and is a terrible finisher. If you compare Haye his finishing ability to Muhammad Ali you can see how bad it is
I'd say Haye, even prime-vs-prime. Speed is everything. Also, as pointed out above, Haye often throws from odd angles, which keeps his opponent from deflecting. That EFFECTIVELY increases his punch's power. ------------------------------------ But now ask: In the HW division, who LANDS the most effective power punches? The answer is easily Vitali.
Haye hits harder based on what? Fat Del? Audley? Not a chance he hits harder, even current Vit, prime Vit destroys him.
Haye has given every single guy he's fought a problem when he hits them hard. He had Wlad holding on in the 12th, put SNV on ***** street and KTFO of Chisora when no-one else had before to mention a few. Vitali is an accumulation puncher, he rarely gets a KO/KD out of nowhere and even fat and supposedly weak-chinned Lewis took his bests shots.