Who is a better fighter, currently - Mosley or Dawson?

The answer is clearly Dawson. I don't get why so many are saying Mosley. Mosley is done as an elite fighter.

 

Miguel Cotto disagrees with you

 

Are you basing that comment off the Vargas KO, the Collazo boxing lesson or the close loss to a bad ass, in his prime Cotto?

And you claim to not be a Mosley hater.

Judah is toast come may 31st pal.

 

shane mosley can almost sell out madison square garden masturbating.

 

Who Has Dawson Beaten?

 

Vargas is a has been(Shane struggled in that first fight with that has been). Tell me what Collazo has done of note in the sport besides beating El Gallo for a bogus WBA regular title. Beating an injured Collazo doesn't mean much. Props to Shane for giving Cotto a good fight, but he still lost. Furthermore, Mosley's style matches up well against a guy like Cotto. Hoya gave Floyd a good fight, does that mean he's still an elite fighter?

Shane is one of my all time favorite fighters

We'll see about that.

 

Glen Johnson, Eric Harding, and Tomasz Adamek. Name me Shane's last big win.

 

Struggled in the first fight? Are you nuts? Mosley blew the mans eye off his face. Collazo had just lost a questionable decision to Hatton so he's no scrub and Cotto is a top 5 P4P fighter in his prime. Mosley is past his prime but he's still better than Dawson.

How can you say Dawson beat old ass Glen Johnson with a straight face?

 

Yeah, with a headbutt. The fight wa still pretty close at the time of the stoppage

So, besides beating El Gallo, you're telling me Collazo biggest achievement in the sport is losing to Hatton?

Mayweather is the top p4p fighter and in his prime. I guess Hoya is better than Dawson as well.

Quite easily, considering Dawson did in fact win. Tell me with a straight face that Mosley beat Hoya in the 2nd fight.

 

Headbutt my ass. That's called straight right hands friend. Watch the fight again, that wasn't caused by any headbutt. You just bought into the Vargas excuse brigade.

I never said Collazo was some world beater. Mosley made easy work of a man that 'arguably' lost to Hatton. That's all I said.

Why do you keep bringing up DLH? We're talking about Mosley being better than Dawson... which the poll clearly suggest I'm right and your wrong.

Your wrecking ball Dawson got a gift over old ass Johnson. Period.
I've said repeatedly on here that I though DLH won the rematch with Mosley.

 

BigReg,

Dawson did NOT beat Glen Johnson. He was given a favored gift.

 

Klion, Dawson did beat Johnson. I saw it with my own two eyes. All 3 judges scored it for Dawson, as did most of press row. I don't know why people can't accept that they just scored the fight wrong.