Who is higher on the ATG list: Floyd Mayweather (so far) or Roberto Duran?

Duran is higher.

Floyd needs pac and after that maybe Martinez or better to say GGG on resume.don't need to win against GGG but atleast make it competitive.after that i think many posters would say it's depatable who is higher all-time.

agree or disagree?

and no i'm not saying after that floyd is higher,but after that it could be somewhat serious question?

 

floyd should not even be mentioned in same breath as duran total insult f

 

lol poll is very telling

 

G.O.A.T 135 + W over Prime Top 25 P4P/#2 ATG Welter
G.O.A.T 130 + null

Duran double digits above Mayweather on the P4P list, Mayweather blew his only chance to fight an ATG P4P in his prime :roll: with the things going the way they are now it will remain the same...unless Canelo becomes artificially the 154 G.O.A.T. Against his will :yep

Defeating GGG or Ward is a long shot...worth it...but Mayweather wants to bust Marciano balls

 

We'll you can't quit if you didn't have the balls to get in the ring in the first place because your health come first

 

Brandish, bremen, emallini, floyd_g.o.a.t, Greco, HoldMyBeer, LordSouness

LOL! must be MVC's alts.

 

Floyd is the better fighter h2h, Duran has the better legacy.

 

I don't think anyone is serious when they say Floyd is greater than Duran unless they're around 15 and really don't know anything about Duran.

I remember I used to say Duran was the least greatest out of the Fab 4 when I knew nothing much about the Fab Four, turns out Duran is 8-13th in the ALL TIME rankings.

Duran's career is one of THE most interesting careers. Learn about it.

 

duran is... im actually not sure how floyd overtakes him.. even if he viciously beats down pac.. maybe couple that with a win over GGG at 160..

 

lol there was an espn poll on who was greater out of duran and pac aswell as another poll out of SRR and pac

pac was leading both by landslide (this was about, 2 years ago btw)

 

That's basically like saying..What does Floyd have to do to be 10th in All time rankings...

Well, Golovkin at 160lbs, Pacquiao at 147lbs, someone like Carl Froch at 168lbs..or am I just taking a **** with the Carl Froch part?

 

i think he is a lock for top 20 and if he beats pac he could be closing in on the top 10