Who is higher on your all time list?

Ask me in 5 years. I find it hard to place active fighers in all time lists. IMO stuff like that needs time to marinate and a couple of years of inactivity to fully appreciate what a fighter has / hasn't acheived, and the manner of it.

 

At the moment it's Joshua. Due to Fury not having defended a single belt yet, his weak opposition next to Wlad and Wilder, and the fact that he should have been banned at the time he had his career defying win.
But it's much to early days for a real conclusion.

 

Neither

 

Fury. Although AJ may have a better resume, Fury has bigger wins in Klitschko and Wilder.

 

AJ - Far superior resume and actually defend his world title.

AJ notable wins - Wlad, Povetkin, Whyte, Parker, Ruiz and Pulev.

Furys's notable wins: Wlad, Chisora and Wilder.

There's a massive gulf in resume depth and quality (after their Wlads, AJ has beaten 5 guys more impressive than Furys next best win which is debatable between Chisora and Wilder.)

If AJ beats the former undisputed CW champ and the best CW ever in Uysk (big if though and I think Usyk will win) then gap i quality and depth of each others resume will only increase.

 

Hollyfield is the CW to move up and peform best at HW. However comparing the two resumes at CW it's clear Usyk has by far superior resume.

 

No he's not.
He's a greater boxer overall without any doubt due to his HW run, even taking being a blatant cheater into consideration.
But at Cruiser the gap in opposition and circumstances in which the fights took place, it's clearly Usyk.

 

boxing historians will say fury

casuals will say joshua

 

So, you vote Joshua?

 

Fury now. Joshua if he beats Usyk.
Furys legacy will fade out if he doesn't get active

 

No, but why would he have to beat them twice? With names like Huck (Cruiser defence record holder, 13 defences), Briedis (3 of the major belts seperate, WBC twice + WBSS winner), Hunter, Bellew (WBC), Gassiev (IBF/WBA), and Glowacki (WBO) -all in their backyards-, on the list, he trumps Holyfield clearly at Cruiser.

 

Neither has done squat to even consider this discussion.