Who is more skilled at their best ?... TONEY or HOPKINS ?

Hmmm, I'd say Hops only because he was a little more varied in what he could do. Although Toney was as supremely skilled on the inside as any other fighter in history. In a toe-to-toe inside battle he'd probably owns Hops.

 

The Jones knockdown was a shove. The knockdown was not a product of a flush shot. Let's see Bernard go to heavy and take heavyweight caliber shots. Taylor and Echols had him dazed a few times. I think if they were to fight at middle it would be a very close fight. Let's be honest here, Toney would also have beat De La Hoya, Trinidad, and Tarver. I don't see Hopkins beating McCallum.