Who is pound for pound number 3

You have mistaken my reasoning for having Hopkins over Calzaghe. I thought Hopkins won the fight, but it was not what I would classify as a "robbery" and I would only overturn blatant robberies for the purposes of rankings. When a fight is as close as Hopkins-Calzaghe, I tend to discount it entirely rather than overturn it.

So I don't count that fight, so I judge them on the basis of their recent form.

Hopkins has dominated linear lightheavyweight champion Antonio Tarver, became the first man in 8 years to beat Winky Wright, and produced a masterclass to shutout undefeated p4p#5 Kelly Pavlik.

Calzaghe has slapped the diabolical Peter Manfredo to a premature stoppage, had one quality win over Mikkel Kessler, and slapped around the corpse of Roy Jones in a sham money fight.

No contest IMO.

 

No, actually, I read it quite clearly.

As I said that exactly mirrors my reasoning for personally ranking Marquez above Pacquaio.

I scored the fight between them to Marquez and he scores higher on other recent opposition: Casamayor, Juarez, Barrera v Solis, Barrera, Diaz.

 

1.Pac
2.JMM
3.Calz
4.Hop

 

Fair enough then, I disagree but a valid call.

 

1. pac
2. jmm
3. calzaghe

 

Pacquiao

 

Pac
JMM
Calz
Hop

 

Manny PAcquaio is 3rd on my list. Cal is 1, Hopkins is 2, Pac is 3. Pac would be 4 if Floyd were still ranked pfp best.

 

I know lol. You have to understand, he uses ALT's to belittle anyone who disagrees with him, and he even analyzed Cal's opponents resume's lol.

 

JMM all the way