This is a good question. I would have to say it's close between Johnson and Tarver. I give johnson the slight edge because he doesnt seem to have diminished as much as Tarver. He also put up a much better fight against Dawson than Tarver did.
atsch **** i voted for tarver when i meant to vote for johnson. 1. Johnson 2. Tarver 3. Jones 4. Holy
Don't worry. We know you meant Johnson. It's not even close. The gap between 1st and 2nd is huge, the gap between 2nd and 3rd pretty big also.
I have Johnson as the #1 Holyfield as the #2 and the reason I have Holyfield there is that he has been able to still compete with the top Heavyweights Ohh **** forgot about Hopkins, make Evander #3