who is the best of these 3 fighters

Carlos Baldomir.
He was the lineal WW champion, making him the top WW.

 

Koki Kameda

 

Manny Pacquiao.

 

****! I voted for the wrong Oscar, meant the one that beat Tito..........

 

Some floyd fans just educated me on how amazing baldomir was and that since he was lineal champ he was the best boxer until floyd beat him.

 

And you still won't admit that PBF was the linear champ at WW.

 

Of course he was the lineal champ.
He just wasn't a top WW.
Neither was Baldomir.

 

u idiot he fought gatti at 140.

 

thats a tough one...im not liking the dlh-chavez one because chavez at that point had like over 100 fights, de la hoya was simply too young, fresh and fast...with the gatti fight, floyd brutally pummeled him for 6 rounds (or was it five)...those shots he was landing, the pinpoint accuracy the speed, was just amazing...however the pac knockout was super violent, but it only lasted two rounds, and ricky had a bit of sucess in the second round...considering the opponent (i believe gatti was a more skillful fighter, had more heart and a better chin than hatton), im going to go with floyd.

 

Mayweather.

 

The FM that beat Gatti was so perfect he was like something from a cartoon, sublime, punch-perfect, a true masterclass in every sense of the word.

You would have to be very biased to vote for ANY version of MP over him, especially one were you only had under 2 rds to see his stuff..... FM went thru every punch in the book & landed over 60% while taking close to ****in 0 from what I seen, amazing display, you cant compare a 2 rd demolishion job to that sort of thing IMO.
You put both versions in that ring together & MP would be on the bad end of an ass whuppin, pulled out by his corner in rd 10 humiliated.... why you think he walked ? :think

DLH was the bigger guy vs an old Chavez so that takes away from his a bit compared to the other 2 but great performance nonetheless.

 

What a surprise PH|LLA.

I hadnt even opened the thread and I knew it would in some way try and praise Pac and behold!


Change the record, yawn.