who is the best of these 3 fighters

Mayweather

 

Mayweather and Oscar have never lost to a shot fighter, or two unknown journey men.

I can't see Pac beating a prime DLH.

Mayweather went to a SD against an aging Oscar.

Prime Oscar was so much better than the version PBF fought.

Obviously the version that Pac fought would have lost to even Calderon.

 

Damn good poll, and hard to decide. Gatti at his very best wouldn't have had a chance in Hell against Floyd Mayweather at his very worst...Pacquiao took Hatton out too damn quick. He didn't have to overcome any adversity. I guess I would have to go with Oscar, but that is not to say that the Oscar that beat Chavez could beat the Pacquiao who beat Hatton, or the Mayweather who beat Gatti...

 

Oscar by far he dominated a still great fighter. Floyd's win over Gatti is not that impressive he just did the same thing Oscar, Manfredy, Baldomir and Gomez did to Gatti. That Pacquiao is amazing but gets KOed savegly by prime Oscar.

 

Hard to say really. All formidable fighters at 140 and capable of beating each other.

 

I'm going to change my vote to "neither". It's just too hard to say. Mayweather did look absolutely flawless against Gatti, but come on...it was Gatti...I will say this, though, do you think Gatti could have took those punches from Pacquiao and not went down? Oscar was much younger and fresher than Chavez, and Pacquiao simply took advantage Hatton's mistakes.

 

Oh the certified pac hater is back...

still in the fantasy world...still in the fantasy world of ...would have...could have! :rofl

 

Your are one delusional ****ed up individual that obviously doesnt understand styles of fighters = different looking results.

Funny how you picked THIS CURRENT VERSION of FM to beat THAT VERSION of MP when you thought the fight was a go ahead & this version of FM was if anything, lesser than the version that beat Gatti :think.... dont give me the size bull**** because we all know its minimal enough to let the BETTER FIGHTER decide the outcome.

FM could go out there & dominate MP for 11 straight rds like he did JMM & punctuate it with a blinding KO in the 12th & you would still refuse to admit that he is superior to MP... the `size` would likely be your get out clause.

Thats all !

 

Assuming both win & they actually get the fkn thing signed this time around.... Id take a bet with anyone, avater, months off etc. that FM will beat his ass.

 

Its hard for me to say being as how they all fought different opponents with way different styles.....

But I will say, Head 2 Head at that time period, Mayweather is the best in my opinion.

 

The reason being that FM cannot get below the WW limit anymore, he would be a walking corpse.

You cant seriously believe that the 130 lb version of MP would beat the 130 lb version of FM... please tell me you werent heading in that direction.

 

Beat him without contraversy, proving his superiority.