who is the best overall boxer of this five at JWW

True, it shouldn't, Manny established himself as the best Featherweight of the last 10 years by beating that beast 3K Battery.

 

The thread didn't ask to rank their achievements, it simply asked for the best OVERALL BOXER. :nono Achievement and ability are two separate issues.

 

exactly, they are connected but they are not the same thing.

Its not like Pac doesn't have many achievements at 140 becasue he wasn't good enough to do it. He only fought there once. We can only specualate one way or the other.

 

True. They are equivalent to the Julio Cesar Vasquez or Esteban De Jesus of their respective eras but not ATG's...

 

HtH
Chavez
Pacquiao Just barely above Pryor
Pryor
Tszyu
Hatton

Resume at JW
Chavez
Pryor
Tszyu
Hatton
Pacquiao

 

pryor on PED
pac
jcc
KT
Hatton

 

Tszyu was a better overall boxer at lww than Pryor? Yeah, I can see prime Hawk being knocked out by Vince ****ing Phillips.

Hatton was a better overall boxer at lww than Pacquiao? Eamonn Magee would probably give Pac hell too. Your petty dislike is causing you to lose control of your brain.

 

1.Pryor
2.Chavez
3.Pac
4.Tszyu
5.Hatton

 

Chavez
Pryor
Tszyu
Pac
Hatton

 

Why even add that when you are a Pacquiao fan? You are just inciting hatred against him.

 

This. So much, this.

 

Good rankings H2H Pacman would dominate them all imo.

 

1. Chavez
2. Pryor
3. Pacquiao
4. Tszyu
5. Hatton

 

Agreed. Tszyu wasn't the calibre of Pryor

 

No, he would not.

Both Chavez & Pryor would be too much for him.