difficult one. except for dawson and in a lesser way kessler, they all have a case. for now i say pavlik.
1. Miguel Cotto 2. Mikkel Kessler 3. Kelly Pavlik/Chad Dawson 4. Kelly Pavlik/Chad Dawson 5. Wladimir Klitschko
i think its funny that pavlik and kessler are above dawson, yet dawson is the much more tested fighter.
Cotto is first because he's a top 10 P4P fighter right now and he has a great resume. I have Wlad second because he's been doing it the longer than the rest and is clearly the best HW. Pavlik is 3 because he's the Linear MW champ Dawson is 4th because he has beaten two solid fighters in Adamek and Johnson Kessler 5 because he lost to Calzaghe but has beaten Andrade and Mundine. If this is going by talent and not accomplishments then my list would be 1.Dawson 2.Cotto 3.Kessler 4.Pavlik 5.Wlad