Who is The Greatest Asian Fighter of All time???

*******s need to stop using the P4P argument when A he got there by Floyd retiring and B P4P wasnt around during the time of his competition.

 

let's see what happens with the diaz fight... if pac beats diaz, he will only be the asian fighter to hold sanctioned belts in 4 weight classes as well as being a 3-weight lineal champ... that will clearly make him the most accomplished among all asian fighters in boxing history and this includes harada, elorde and pancho villa. that should be more than enough to make him the greatest asian boxer to date.

greatest asian FIGHTER ever is bruce lee...

 

No, that's where you're wrong, because you're looking at accomplishments in a sense of winning belts, not in terms of beating the best opposition. That's where the Mayweather fans are off with their rating of Floyd as well. David Diaz is not what seperates the two.

 

:rofl

 

You are a bad guy.

 

:rofl Was that a serious comparison?

You are really mind-boggling me right now. Are you this simple?

And?

First of all, that Fighter of the Decade nonsense you posted was an opinion of someone on an opposing board, and you're really trying to place it in Pacquiao's list of accomplishments? Mayweather had to retire for Pac to take the mantle, and they didn't even have P4P rankings back in Harada's day, otherwise he'd possibly have been at the top after his wins over Harada.

And we've already discussed the rest ad nauseam, and instead of refuting any of my earlier points, you just post the same nonsense again, which I've already answered. Harada fought and beat the better competition, bottom line. He was the more skilled fighter in a deeper era.

 

What qualifies anyone as an expert?

 

Sweet Pea were all lounge chair Experts.

Man im an expert and id class you an expert.

Of all the same whoever can get there opinion across the best.

Sweet Pea i feel you need to get over the fact Tszyu would KO Whitaker.:yep :rofl :good

 

The best boxer ever is SRR hands down, there is NO COMPETITITION:nono

Maybe someday we'll see somone top his accomplishments but given todays circumstances its highly improbable.

Pacdbest? i credit Pac, like him, but be a bit rationale. There is no plane of reason that places him at #1 AT:nono

 

Koizumi is an award-winning HOF author of boxing and he stated this? Good for him, doesn't prove a damn thing really, unless he provided reason in comparison to a guy like Harada, which I doubt he did.

I don't think someone needs awards and HOF honors to have an opinion that counts. As has been said, guys like Atlas and Sugar have boatloads of knowledge, yet their bias and lack of anlytical ability places them with the rest of us, as flawed interpreters. A guy like Raging B(_)LL has seen more than enough of every fighter he comments on, and has a more extensive knowledge than anyone I've ever heard of, and provides excellent analysis and detail for his debates. I'm more impressed by someone like that than I am Teddy Atlas.