Who is the greatest NON-ATG Fighter in your book?

You're saying that those lists were shitty when you gave me one from a list in the classic forum? Damn, irony.

 

So I don't understand, the guy asked me to post a list with Trinidad and I posted 3.

 

This became an arguement about Trinidad being top 100? lol

 

Well if 3 different lists from renowned boxing websites isn't proof, then I don't know what is.

 

prince hamed is the greatest

 

Zab Judah.
Smoked to much weed in his prime, hung with the wrong people.
Without those setbacks and with focus , determination and mental strength he could of been great. He had the skills.
Only guy to ever drop Mayweather.

If Tony Tucker was around to today people would be calling him an ATG. He'd box circles around both Klitschko's at his best.
So would Golota if he had the mindset of Wladimir.

 

Is Camacho Sr an atg?

 

Does anyone class Ike Quartey as an ATG? He was a helluva fighter in his prime, and him against either Pea or Tito would have been very interesting.

Curry has already been mentioned. ATG skills at his best, but not quite the resume to back it up (although he wasn't quite the flash in the pan some make out)

Luis Rodriguez often doesn't get the credit he deserves. Superb fighter.

 

Not as much as me watching Oscar outland Trinidad 3-1, man to man :happy

 

about.com is a renowned boxing website is it? :rofl

 

You should just give up, bro. It's looking pretty bad for you.

 

I would put Norris at 3 at 154.

 

If I had to put a number on the amount of fighters through history that I deem ATG's, it would probably be 50. The 50 best fighters ever.

 

Calzaghe is a great choice

 

is joe 'old bones' brown considered an all time great?

simon brown was great in his time, I thought.