Who is the greatest NON-ATG Fighter in your book?

Gerald McClellan.

 

Let's wrap this up, not gonna sit here arguing for 2 hours saying the same **** when you've already been proven wrong. This is the 3rd time I'm saying this now because you're too stupid to understand, probably due to the fact that Trinidad got a win from your boi on your avatar. You said Trinidad wasn't ATG, I posted proof saying otherwise. That's all that there is to say.

 

I said he wasn't top 100 ATG. Read the thread.

PS - here - Learn something :hi:

http://www.boxing.com/the_100_greatest_fighters_of_all_time_part_ten_10_1.html

 

I think he means "Gifted"..he was gifted a win over my boi in my avatar :think

 

Gonna wrap this up with you too. Let's just agree that Pac is greater than Harada, I'm sure 99% of the people in this world who are boxing fans would agree. You even agreed. So there's no point in saying anything else.

 

Yet he posts lists that have no Sam L, no Terry, no Holman, no Fitzsimmons.....

Safe to say which lists are the laughable ones.

 

He got the win, brah.. then after that lost to Mosley a couple fights later. It's clear that Trinidad took his soul. We can take that win away though and take Oscar's win away from a coked up Whitaker. :deal

 

See, this is the thing with lists. If you wanna have fighters who fought 100 years ago, then okay. It's impossible to rate fighters who fight in the 1800's and early 1900's along with fighters who fought today. There should be separate lists, boxers from late 1800's to 1940's, and boxers from 1950's to today.

 

Go right ahead and that makes Trinidad a complete hypejob who's best W was arguably Vargas

 

Andddddd end thread.

 

Not really, DLH would've been ridiculed for losing to a coked up druggie while Trinidad would of beaten Whitaker 2 fights later and still unify the titles while the likes of DLH get beaten by a Lightweight. Either way, your hero would of still been a coke head himself and dress in drag.

 

How exactly though? Boxing in those days wasn't as universal as it is now. Fights back then were only between people in North America and Britain. And black fighters weren't allowed to fight till Joe Louis broke the color barrier.

 

OMG . . . you literally read my mind. This is my list except for Hamed, who upon further reflection is one of them.

quick what number am i thinking of:yep

 

Yeah, actually.

Oscar's res without Whitaker, and adding the Trinidad W-
Hernandez
Carr
Leija
Paez
Quartey
Campas
Gatti
Ruelas
Gonzales
Chavez Sr.
Trinidad
Vargas
Castijello
Rivera
Mayorga

Trinidad without Oscar ->
Campas
Carr
Blocker
Reid
Mayorga
Joppy
Thiam
Whitaker
Cherifi
Vargas
Pineda


It's not even remotely close :rofl

 

Oscar was a lightweight too you fool so how does that help Trinidad at all :rofl