Who is the LEAST deserving fighter since 1990 to be labeled an ATG by his fans?

These are the following fighters which have fans calling them 'ATG'S.


Yet a lot of fans also rage that they are NOT ATGS and just Hall of Famers.

Who do you think among this list is LEAST deserving of an ATG ranking.
1-Roy Jones Jr- I say he is HOF, not ATG. His resume consists of beating a green Hopkins and Toney. I give him the Toney win because that was a prime Toney (regardless of weight drain). But for these idiots saying that 'Hopkins' he beat was prime . That Hopkins Roy beat was no where near the skill levels of the Hopkins of 2000+.


2-Vitali Klithscko.
I like Vitaly. I think he is a great HOF Fighter.
Pros of Vitaly- he is tall.
Cons:
Quitter. Ped User. Rager. Complainer. C Rated Politican. Semi Good Brother. HOFer. This describes Vitali.
ATG does not.


3- Joe Calzaghe- . He dominated his division and beat a better Hopkins then most people realized. Fighting Roy was a joke, but who cares. Roy wanted it.

4- James Toney
I actaully heard people call him an ATG? I don't know if they meant ATG Skill level. But that is pure bull****. HOFer for sure. ATG is not him.


5-JMM
Make a case for this guy if you like. I think he is an ATG. But if you can make a case that he's not and is just a HOFer. Do it.

6-Felix Trinidad.
Same. Make a case if you think Trinidad is NOT an ATG.

7- Julio Ceasar Chavez Senior.
Will like someone to break down this guy's resume for me, it honestly don't look that strong.But maybe I don't know the whole story.

8-Riddick Bowe.
I think he's borderline ATG.

9-Other
List someone you feel have fans calling him ATG, but is not.

 

Fine, they are both not ATGS. Happy?

I just read through a thread on ESB the 'Did ROY Jones started losing when he stepped up' thread.

This poster HeadBanger and this other poster Bailey made much stronger points then everyone else.

You have to realize, I mostly watch HW Boxing and does not focus on smaller weights. Which means a lot of Royformation that I'm getting comes from this site. ESB. The site you post on.

 

I did.

It's still confusing to me. Explain this(if you know).


Everyone states Roy Jones Jr was weight drained after Ruiz, yet they forgot that Roy won the first Tarver fight. I got it 8-4, after watching it. It was a fair decision against a Prime LHW Elite in Tarver.

The next fight, which happened several monthes later. Roy got brutally knocked the **** out. He never recovered.

How is it he was 'weight drained', yet won the first fight, had time to recover, then started getting knocked ice out.

So the Anti ROy's theories of 'Oh cause he got off the juice' and 'because he finally stepped up in LHW, competition wise' sound a lot more believable then 'he got old'