Who is the most overrated fighter ?

valero by a mile

 

On the overrated scale (1-10, 1 being Guzman and 10 being Margarito) H2H today:

Clinton Woods - 4
Antonio Tarver - 8.5
Edison Miranda - 8
Anthony Mundine - 2
Paulie Malignaggi - 4
Arthur Abraham - 3
Edwin Valero - 9.5
Kermit Cintron - 4
Paul Williams - 7.5

 

Speaking about overrated.. Let's talk abou the guy in your avatar, huki... He is a big ko waiting to happen. WHO NEXT!!! Alexander Povektin.. future heavyweight bum

 

B) Antonio Tarver. Even though people don't think the world of him anymore, he is actually worse still.

 

Very good. I agree with this - not sure about Valero, since I have never seen him fight.

 

After the Chambers fight he actually became slightly underrated. The majority of people think he would lose to Chagaev and Ibragimov, fighters he should be favored against.

Valero is insanely overrated, there are C+ level 130 pounders out there that could beat him. All one needs to beat him is a solid chin and mediocre boxing skills. He's a knockout artist who hasn't even scored one KO against any B levels yet, but has showed numerous flaws including a shaky chin.

Tarver is going to get stopped by Woods, I rewatched his last 2 fights on showtime recently and he's shot. After that, Woods will most likely become a 7 on the scale.

 

And what makes a Sam Peter fan the authority of whose overrated?

There's my overrated choice right there.

 

Glenn Kelly is the boxer RJJ beat with hands behind his back. He was an undefeated Australian boxer coming into that fight.

Kelly was ruined by Jones. Paul Briggs KO'd Kelly in 4rds about a year or 2 later. I think that was one of his last fights.

 

Sam Peter fan? :?

 

Of the list supplied I beleive that Woods is the most overrated, although Tarver is nearing the end of his career I see a tko inside 8 rounds. A strong case could be made for Valero being overrated but I see a few people have said he has been hurt a few times, this is clearly not the case. He has been hit plenty of times but hurt? NO!
I love watching Valero fight, all action, no ***** footing around, straight in bish bash bosh, goodnight vienna!

:hey

 

Most KO artists have weak chins - but I believe everything you say here - the Woods thing included.

Forgot to say that your pts were very well set, which was the most part of were I agreed. Can't agree on Margo though, but the rest are spot on - to an almost eerie extent.

 

Samuel Peter.

 

UM actually that was Glen Kellyatsch

 

He is a beltholderatsch If anything he is underrated

 

I think a case could be made for most of those, but I don't know that many people who actually rate Tarver or Paulie.

I think people are thinking of Cotto and Pavlik as being the second coming, they are top class fighters, but still overrated IMO.