Who looked the most impressive against Broner: Maidana, Porter, Garcia, or Pacquiao

Maidana did he beat the best version of him even dropped him and was expected to lose.

 

Styles matter. Broner tried to fight maidana in the pocket. He tried to walk maidana down, ran and turtles up against Pac like usual. I called it, broner wasn’t gonna be a statue, man was gonna get on his bike and try emulate Floyd.

 

Maidana beat up Broner the worst and it was a fresher, probably more focused Broner. But Broner also hit Maidana a lot more than he hit Mickey or Pacquiao. Pac schooled the hell out of Broner and if it was the same Broner Maidana beat I'd say Pac but I don't think it's the same Broner.

 

Maidana. Mikey the least.

 

He came into the Maidana fight as a "big deal" and was expected to handle Maidana easily. He fought differently than he did, say Pac. In the Pac fight he didn't come to win. Maidana shook him BAD.
He gave Maidana every opportunity to beat him up. He didn't do that with Pac and was on his bike a lot.

 

Pacquiao's win was far and away the most impressive.

Broner believed that Maidana was DONE when they fought. He was embarrassed by Devon Alexander, mentally quit, and gave a long and serious think about retiring. They rebuilt him against Soto Karass and a couple other stiffs after Alexander but he was a serious betting underdog for a reason. Maidana didn't have the street cred he has now from the Mayweather fight.

Broner had a real trainer and got in real shape for the Pacquiao fight.

Being a 40yr old man and beating a well trained, in-shape Broner is much more impressive than anything Maidana or Garcia did.

 

Except Broner came on late, walked forward with a high guard, and was hurting Maidana. Maidana called Broner the toughest guy he's ever fought. Broner never ran from Maidana. Pacquiao dominated Broner winning 10-11 rounds, hurt him more than Maidana ever did (even though no KDs), and had Broner RUNNING in the late rounds (where Broner usually excels).

Pacquiao never got out of 3rd gear in beating Broner and he did so while being 40 and smaller.

 

Garcia shut him out

 

Pacquiao was 40 and Garcia was coming up in weight, but Maidana knocked him down twice, took his 0, and let's not forget his dry humping.

 

I was gonna say pac. But maidana humped broner and that's gonna score some big points

 

Lol. I think. Maidana damaged broner the most . And I think maidana did better against Floyd than pac did

 

I would say Maidana as well (although he lost more rounds than the other three did) purley because he beat Broner at a time when he was undefeated and many were calling him the new Mayweather and virtually no one gave Maidana a chance.