Who of these guys has the Higher ATG status?

ATG? Neither, who have they beaten to be mentioned as ATG?

 

Joe Calzaghe - won the WBC, WBA, WBO, and IBF belts to become the first undisputed super middleweight champion in divisional history. Defeated Chris Eubank, Mikkel Kessler, Jeff Lacy, Robin Reid, Mario Veit twice, Byron Mitchell, and Charles Brewer. Better overall wins than DM and overall, a better resume.

 

Hmm, good question...I'm going to go with Dariusz by a close decision just based on the fact that I've seen him there and have yet to see Calzaghe at 175.

 

Calzaghe, without question. DM, while talented, was just another hometown boy who was as just to blame for not making certain fights happen as anyone else.

 

Bum |----DM--------------------------------------------Calzaghe| ATG

Hope this helps

 

He's not quite a bum, look at my official revolutionary rate-o-meter again please

However he's closer to bum than he is to the great Calzaghe

Thus says TFFP

 

Sorry neither of these guys qualify for ATG

 

Calzaghe hands down:deal

 

Close comparison, but I think with Calzaghes last fight against Kessler just put him over DM's accomplishments. They are both very similiar career wise, both have lousy resumes for having long time championship reigns.

 

Calzaghe over Darius.

Its shocking how underrated Darius is by American fans, like he did not win titles in two weight classes, and unified light heavyweight titles and linear title and was 48-0.