who out of there prime lost a fight they still would have lost in there prime

You must be out yo ****in mind!

 

maybe im being a bit harsh, but jc gets no love on this forum, im 90% sure jc would beat bhop every time

 

Ali - Liston

 

Pavlik - Hopkins atsch Oh wait!

 

Calzaghe beats any Eubank.

 

lewis still beats tyson.

and i know ill get **** for this, but...

marciano still beats louis.


oh shi....

 

It don't matter. Prime Mosely beats prime Vargas

I think prime Pac beats prime Morales.

 

Muhammad Ali-Sonny Liston
Marvin Hagler-Bennie Briscoe
Pernell Whitaker-Jose Luis Ramirez

 

Tyson would always lose to Lewis

10 times out of 10

 

10 out of ten is a bit rich, Lewis was knocked out twice and Tyson has great power.

 

Floyd Mayweather-Arturo Gatti
George Foreman-Joe Frazier
Jack Johnson-James Jeffries
Bernard Hopkins-John David Jackson
Oscar De La Hoya-Yori Boy Campas

 

Hagler to Leonard IMO

 

Prime Erik was at 122 - Erik beats his ass in that class but Pac beats Erik`s ass from 135 upwards as Pac is peak now.

Morales wins everytime from 126 downwards
Pacman wins everytime from 135 upwards
The best 130 version of each is a toss-up IMO - you have the Pac from the 2nd/3rd Morales fights vs the Morales from probably the Hernandez fight & you DEFINITELY get a distance fight & LIKELY a debatable Pac JMM kinda close contest but I`ll take the better technical boxer to edge him out (bet yer all shocked eh ?) Erik Morales.

:good

 

Have to agree with the others. Eubank to Calzaghe isn't a great example. Chris took that fight on short notice and wasn't the same fighter. That said, a case can be made that with the exception of three of the first four rounds he could have received the nod and a close decision. He was winded and on a respirator from the introductions but Joe was more distressed in the final seconds of the 12th than Chris was the entire fight from Joe's offense including the flash knockdown in the first. Prime Eubank is slightly above prime Calzaghe. Who did Joe ever fight that was prime while he was prime to rate him so highly? Joe fought Chris and not a single fighter as decent as that past peak version of Eubank for about ten years (if not his entire career - with the only exception being BH - arguably, as he was as gray as Gandalf). Being undefeated gets ya a lot of acclaim. But, the truth rests with the level of comp you face (in all sports).