Who ranks higher ATG list.. De La hoya, pac, PBF?

Who has Floyd ever faced in his weight class even close to a Marquez.

The only things he has even close are Castillo and Corrales and as good as they are Marquez is miles above them.

 

I like Marquez, but I think we are getting all caught up with his almost wins with Pac. I really don't think Marquez is miles ahead of either. It seems to me that Marquez has gotten better with age. A Marquez fight with Castillo would be close at 135 and I am speaking of Marquez of that time. Chico may lose, but you can never count him out ala the Castillo fight. Pac could have lost to either of the two due to not being the fighter he is now which is a whole new ballgame.

 

first off, Quartey and Whitaker he lost, now if you wanna say he won then take the Strum win from him which would only make him a 5 weight class champ. Chavez was old as hell, but he lost to Mosley 2 times, ran like a ***** against Tito, barley won 4 rounds against Mayweather and got destroyed by Hopkins and little as Pacquiao. how the hell is he in front of Pac and PBF??

 

Yea he may get a little overrated due to his fights with Pac. But he's stiil done big things before and after Pac. To go above his comfortable weight and still take out big guns at 135.

Even without Marquez he demolished a prime Barerra and is a 4 weight lineal champ.

Hard to say how they would have fared with Chico or Castillo just because in their primes they were bigger guys. But I think Juans accuracy and ability to adjust would prevail.

 

Oscar #1 one..

PBF and Pac undecided. They are still active. If they both retired today? That's tough, but I'd say Floyd because he's undefeated, but it's close. Both guys need a few more key fights to overtake Oscar's legacy.

 

As far as resume goes I'd have Pac first followed by Hoya and Floyd. I'm looking at their big wins and big fights they did good in. Floyd has the talent just not the resume in my eyes.

As for Hoya. Sturm, Quartey,Whittaker,Mosley2 were all very close fights. The Tito fight wasn't even close. People were just never used to seeing Hoya on the backpedal like that. So the judges somehow gave that fight to Tito.
For the Mayweathr fight it was also very close against an aging unaccurate Hoya who couldn't pull the trigger or properly cut off the ring. I felt Floyd won a very close fight, However I was watching with peiople who felt Oscar did enough.

 

For me De la hoya is the only ATG in that list
aslong as pac keeps going on about catch weight fights and floyd doesnt fight some legit welters i wont have no respect for them

 

Thats why nobody can take your post serious when you say **** like " Mayweather fight also was very close" WHO THE **** THOUGHT THAT FIGHT WAS CLOSE???atschatsch Damn rookies, learn abouyt boxing then come back. that fight wasnt close at all, I think 116-112 for Mayweather is being nice. all this SD is all BS because you know he had to have 1 GBP judge there.

 

That's how I know you're full of ****. You claim Oscar lost all his big fights then when I bring them to light you cling on the May fight.

Look man talk some sense not just some biased bull****.

 

your a loser!!!

 

Like many stated before it's:

Pac
Floyd
Oscar

Simple.

 

Bring what to lite?? yes DLH has beating some decent guys but lost almost all his big fights. the facts are facts, and to you think you really though hes gonna beat Pacquiao...DLH HASNT BEAT ANYBODY GOOD IN 7 YEARS!!! How the hell was he gonna beat Pac?? because hes a so called ATG, he can suck it.

 

Man Haters never seem to amaze me. Its PBF and its not close. We have been talking about PBF being a all time great forever now. Pac is better then PBF cause he beat David Diaz, a shot and i mean shot Oscar, and Hatton I don't think so. People over rate Pac cause he has had some exciting fights but PBF beats everyone so easy minus Castillo first fight that it looks like he is never trying. PBF has beat more people that went on to win titles and better comp people just hate.

 

^Oh Really?

RESUME doesn't lie





1. Manny "Pacman" Pacquiao
* First Filipino and Asian with 5 world titles in 5 divisions
* First Boxer in the world with 4 lineal title in different weight class
* 2006 & 2008 Ring Magazine Fighter of the Year
* 2006 & 2008 Boxing Writers Association Of America Fighter of the Year
* WBC Emeritus Champion
* The Ring Magazine #1 Pound For Pound
* 5-Time PSA Sportsman of the Year
* 2008 University Athletic Association of the Philippines (UAAP) Honorary Award for Sports Excellence
* 2008 ***********.com Fighter of the Year
* 2008 Sports Illustrated Boxer of the Year
* 2008 SecondsOut.com Fighter of the Year
* 2008 TheSweetScience.com Boxer of the Year
* 2008 WBC Boxer of the Year
* 2008 Yahoo Sports Fighter of the Year
* 2008 ESPN Star's Champion of Champions
* 2009 TIME 100 Most Influential People (Heroes & Icons Category)
* 2009 Forbes Magazine Celebrity 100 (ranked 57th)

Titles

Major:
* WBC world flyweight champion
* IBF world super bantamweight champion
* WBC world super featherweight champion
* WBC world lightweight champion
Minor:
* OPBF flyweight champion
* WBC international super bantamweight champion
* WBC international super featherweight champion
* IBO world light welterweight champion
The Ring Magazine titles:
* World featherweight champion
* World super featherweight champion
* World light welterweight champion
Lineal Championship titles:
* World flyweight champion
* World featherweight champion
* World junior lightweight champion
* World junior welterweight champion


2. Oscar "Goldenboy" De la Hoya
* 10-time world champion in 6 different weight class
* Ring Magazine Fighter of the Year 1995
* Pound for Pound King 1997
* Generated the most money in boxing history
* 1989 Gold Medalist National Golden Gloves
* 1990 Gold Medalist US National Championships
* 1990 Gold Medalist Goodwill Games
* 1991 Gold Medalist US National Championships
* 1991 Gold Medalist US Olympic Festival
* 1992 Gold Medalist World Championships Challenge
* 1992 Gold Medalist Olympic Games

Titles

* WBO Jr. Lightweight
* WBO Lightweight
* IBF Lightweight
* WBC Light Welterweight
* WBC Welterweight
* WBA Welterweight
* WBC Super Welterweight
* WBC Jr. Middleweight
* WBO Middleweight


3. Floyd "Money" Mayweather
* 6-time world champion in 5 different weight class
* Pound for Pound King 2005-2008
* 1998 and 2007 Ring Magazine Fighter of the Year
* #48 in ESPN Top 50 Greatest Boxer of all Time

Titles

* WBC Jr Lightweight
* WBC Lightweight
* WBC Super Lightweight
* IBF Welterweight
* IBO Welterweight
* IBA Welterweight
* WBC Welterweight
* WBC Super Welterweight

 

OK then since Oscar is ****. Which is Floyds best win in recent history. Are you saying Floyd hasn't beaten anybody worth **** in the last seven years also.