Who ranks higher ATG list.. De La hoya, pac, PBF?

Pac beats a drained Oscar and he gets all those awards in 2008 and mosts were probably made up. Where is his ESB fighter of the year award? He is a very good fighter and will get stopped by the other fighter you are comparing him to; PBF. Love both, but all the awards will not help him win this fight. He is bringing much excitement and that helps boxing like how Oscar use to do.

 

Oscar
Pac
PBF

This is pretty much a question of preference. Oscar is a sure in. PBF is barely hanging on and Pac is an atg newbie so the question should be between Bedwetter and Pac.

 

I also watch the fight several times and thought it was a close fight. I still remember that Oscar won the 8th round and even the commentators agreed, but I recall all judges gave it to PBF. It was a close fight and why is it posters always throwout if you don't agree that they no little about boxing? There opinions and the fight has to be watch with bias against the fighter you don't care for.

 

Nope

next

 

1)Mayweather
2)DLH
3)Pacman

 

Agree with first paragraph, but he did not beat a prime Barrera. I wish we could have seen Marquez fight a priime Barrera and Erik. That would have something. He was left out of those challenges.

 

I would have to lean towards that Oscar should have lost to Whitaker, but not Quartey. He had Quartey in the corner and the ref could have stopped it. It was an amazing fight. As far as Whitaker, Oscar never gave him the rematch that he agreed to give him. I don't blame him, Whitaker is an ATG and he was on a mission if he would have gotten the rematch. Arum was all about the money and promoting the Golden Boy.

 

While he may not have been his absolute best he was still prime in my eyes. I think Pac was taken lightly. I would have loved to see Marquez in on that.

 

Floyds best win was Castillo in my eyes, Corrales is up there too. to say Judah and Hatton wasnt good wins it just hate. DLH is not Mayweathers best win, its not even close to Corrales or Castillo, not even up there with Hatton or Hernadez. DLH is like Mayweathers 5 best win

 

thats cool, if you dont wanna say he lost those then you HAVE to say he lost to Strum which only makes him a 5 weight class champ. you pick, you can have them all

 

atsch this is why ESB is all jacked up, does anybody know boxing. STEVEIE WONDER HAD THE FIGHT 8-4 FOR MAYWEATHER AND HES BLIND!!! kids these days....

 

PAC
Oscar
PBF

 

Pac
PBF
Oscar

the only thing that is debateable is the Pac and PBF for #1 spot. DLH is clearly #3 and if you dont think so then you dont know boxing. espcially when Mayweather and Pac beat DLH

 

I was following your suit when you said Oscar hasn't beat anyone good in 7 years. Coralles and Castillo were over that time period. Judah and Hatton were good wins. But the Judah win was not better than Mayorga. So you're left with Hatton. Which was a good not great win.

What I'm trying to tell you is that Floyd's caliber of fighters don't compare to Pac or Hoya. Not saying he's not talented.

 

So now Spinks and Holmes are better than Ali since they beat him.