Who ranks higher ?... DLH or MOSELY ?

I rank Mosley slightly ahead of DH. Mosley ranks definitely ahead of PBF:

 

So that clearly makes both Mosley and DLH above PBF.

 

I rank Mosley above DLH. I'm not fooled by multiple weight changes, Mosley has better wins over 'Prime' fighters, or to put it better, fighters whom had advantages over him.

 

if berto beats mosley, then he would be outside the top 100 again..i still put DLH and PBF ahead

 

Agreed. 2 criterais count when determining your ATG status.

-Resume and longivity

- winning alphabetic in multipe weight classes especially lighter classes wher the weight jump is not very big does not eman as much as back in the day.

 

DLH still. He fought much better fighters and has bigger wins.

 

mosley! hands down.

 

Compare resumes. for every one great win Mosley has, Oscar has 3.

 

I've always had SSM a little higher than DLH

 

Name them.

Margarito, and ODLH?:roll:

How about

Rafael Ruelas
John John Molina
Ike Quartey
Fernando Vargas
Tito Trinidad
Pernell Whitaker
Gernaro Hernandez
Miguel Angel Gonzalez
Javier Castillejo
and more.

 

Ive got Hoya pretty clearly still.

He just beat better fighters and more of them..Any objective person can see H2H they are about even with 1 fight a piece.

I dont count the "losses" to Tito, Mosley(second time around) and Sturm (which should have been a loss is what Im saying) against him that much..Nor his past prime hiccups against Pac and Mayweather. I look more at the prime wins, which Oscar has the edge in.

I think in my list Ive got them quite a few spots apart but at that stage in the list there isnt much separating people, so the gulf isnt as big as it looks.

 

I'd like to hear a reasonable reason why SSM is ranked higher than DLH. No one has put one forward yet.

 

I did. If you disagree then that's fine, that's what ESB is all about.

 

I said reasonable. You just posted weak opinions.

I posted facts.

DLH beat more prime top fighters than Mosley.