Who ranks higher floyd or manny ?

You don't really count the 8th title do you

Oscar has more of a claim to Sturm's WBO 160 lb belt than Pac does to a 154 lb belt.

 

So since it is so common, name other fighter aside from Sam Langford and manny Pacquiao who actually did it?

 

Mayweather has Cotto, Mosely, Marquez, Hatton, DLH, Judah, Gatti, Castillo (x2), and corrales. Those are the resume making fights I see in his career (ten).

Pac has Marquez (this is controversial, I think we can agree he won at least 1 of these fights so I'll only count it 1), Moseley, Margarito, Cotto, Hatton, DLH, Morales (x2), Barrera x2. Now, I know Barrera was shot the second time, however if you give mayweather a shot Gatti, then you gotta give pac barrera twice. So that also equals ten.

You can split hairs for either fighter. Maybe you want to count, I don't know, Manfredy for PBF. Well you could also give Pac 2 or all 3 of the marquez fights. It can see saw back and forth. PBF is undefeated, Pac has fought over a wider range of weights. Overall this is pretty close I think?

 

Q.Who's better, Who's beten better?
A. Mayweather.

 

Q.Who has never needed a catchweight to gain a championship?
A. Mayweather

 

Q.Who fights oppoents at or near their primec, omming off key wins. Not old washed up and coming off big loses?
A. Mayweather

 

Pacquiao.. there's no real good argument to have Floyd above him , at all.

If you go by resume, Pac is better. If you go by accomplishments, Pac is better. He's a greater fighter, and that won't change even if Floyd beats Martinez or something.

 

Pac's resume and how he compares to the Top 10 ATGs.

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

 

He only needed to cheat 2 pounds and paid 600,000 dollars to gain overwhelming advantage.

 

How is Pac second in ko percentage and Vitali not listed? Is that only in title fights or something?

 

This content is protected

Where's Gayweather????? Bwahhhhhhhhhhhh!

 

That was compared to the consensus top 10 ATG.

 

It's Pac's resume/stats compared to the Top 10 ATGs as published by The Ring Magazine a few years back.

 

floyds so much better then manny that even having this poll suggests you know nothing about boxing
they're not in the same stratosphere

 

You don't really give Pac credit for his "title win" at 150 do you?