Who ranks higher on the ATG list,Roy Jones or Manny Pacquiao

And rightly so.

This content is protected

 

Thanks mate, I've edited it now. I don't mind Manny coming out on top, but lets be fair. This whole "Manny is better because he's won more titles in more weight classes" is laughable. I give Manny huge credit, but you can throw that around to make him the greatest fighter EVER! Is Manny better than SRR based on that?

We need to be fair.

 

He isnt going to come out on top, Loudon. Roy's about to mop this up, Loudon.

http://www.boxingforum24.com/showthread.php?t=451424

 

Pacquiao for sure.

Surprised by the poll results. Oh how Pacquiao has fallen.

 

Wow, 2 polls involving Mayweather and Pacquiao and BOTH, accurately, against their favour...







:happy

 

Everyone knows that I'm a huge fan of Roy's, but I don't mind if Manny comes out on top as long as it's fair.

Take a look at Manny's resume, and it's stacked with ATG's.

Straight away JMM x 4, Morales x 3, and MAB x 2, jump straight out at you. That's 9 incredible fights against 3 ATG fighters. Those fights leap out at you and if you add De la Hoya and Sugar Shane etc it looks Amazing!

But you need to ask the following questions:

Why did he fight JMM 4 times?

Why did he need to fight Morales 3 times?

Why did he need to fight MAB twice?

Roy didn't fight rematches or trilogies in his prime (apart from Griffin) because he never needed too. But now it's been held against him.

If Manny's resume read:

JMM x 1
MAB x 1
Morales x 1

and Roy's read:

Toney x 3
Hop x 3
Ruiz x 2

Then I would expect people to say that Roy had a superior resume. There's lots of factors that need taking into consideration.

A lot of people on here don't allow for circumstances.

Lets do a fair break down.

 

if pac was a brotha' he would be, without a doubt, higher than roy or floyd.

 

Dodong: Worst poster of 2013.

Depressed, miserable, jealous, depressed, miserable, jealous... every post. Only talks about Mayweather in every single post.

---

But yes, Pacquiao is being underrated greatly due to the recent JMM KO.

If this poll was done before the KO, Pac would be ahead, just like he will be in 10 years from now after passionate fans can look back with a clear scope.

 

:good

 

Pac and its not even close! ppl have gone stupid after the KO. Pac stands head and shoulders above Jones and crybaby.

 

Agreed.

 

Only RJJ actually failed a drug test atsch

You *****s are ****ing spasticated.

Was Floyd feasting on Mannys 'scraps' when he fought Marquez and Cotto then?

 

Pac

 

I'm not a Floyd fan *****?