Who ranks higher on your ATG List. Oscar De La Hoya or Floyd Mayweather Jr

Moslye fought mayweather without roids and when he was almost 40

 

Floyd

 

First, in his prime, Oscar only has 2 loses. Out of those two loses, one was a clear robbery against Tito.

The rest of his losses are when he was past his best.

The fact that Oscar has fought more elite fighters, more top fighters, and more champions or more champions needs to be taken into consideration whether he won or lost.

Oscar's best wins are:

Jorge Paez (#2 Contender/Vacant)
John John Molina (Challenger)
Jesse James Leija (Challenger)
Rafael Ruelas

This content is protected

Genaro Hernandez (Challenger)
Miguel Angel Gonzalez (Challenger)
Hector Camacho (Challenger)
Julio Cesar Chavez X2

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

Pernell Whitaker

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

Ike Quartey

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

Tito Trinidad

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

Fernando Vargas

This content is protected

This content is protected

This content is protected

Javier Castillejo

This content is protected

Shane Mosley II (Challenger)
Ricardo Mayorga

This content is protected

Floyd's best wins are:

Genaro Hernandez (Oscar tapped that ass first and better)

This content is protected

Angel Manfredy (Challenger)
Diego Corrales (Challenger)
Jesus Chavez (Challenger)
Jose Luis Castillo X2

This content is protected

Gatti (Not considered a top win for Oscar who beat him 1st)

This content is protected

Zab Judah (Challenger)
Baldomir

This content is protected

Oscar De La Hoya

This content is protected

Hatton (Challenger)
Marquez (Challenger)
Mosley (Challenger)
Ortiz (Challenger)
Cotto (Challenger)


Oscar CLEARLY has the better resume.

 

beat oscar at 154, floyd KO'd a prime undefeated hatton, came out of 18 months retirement and instead of tuning up vs an average fighter he has a tune up fight vs the number 2 P4P fighter in the world JMM and dominates him, (dominated) mosley after mosley KO'd iron chinned margarito, KO'd ortiz the number 2 ranked and WW champion, beat the 154 champion cotto cleanly at his weight.

Remains undefeated.

tito, vargas and faded whitaker :tong

Floyd's gone a have canelo on there soon and maybe pac and possibly bradley. Lots not forget diego on floyd's resume and castillo and gatti and corley was a big fight at the time and floyd won in great fashion.

Floyd wins his fights in a better fashion than oscar more cleanly and he fights the best when they are coming off big wins so it makes the fight a bigger fight in financial terms. He's not scared of them.

Oscar lost to hopkins, pac, mosley. The best names on his resume have a loss next to it:-(

 

Oscar beat tito to!

 

Oscar lost to mosley, was that a typo:nono

When floyd beat them they were:

Ortiz was the 147 champion
Mosley was the 147 champion
cotto was the 154 champion
hatton was champion at 140
marquez was a champion at lightweight
But you forgot that:hi:

Oscar's loss's:

Trinidad
Mosley x2
Hopkins
Floyd :blurp
Manny

Floyd's loss's:

:tong

 

everyone beat tito

 

Two of Floyds Top wins are Gatti, and Hernandez.

Those aren't even top wins for Oscar.

 

true, you do need roids to fight floyd he's that bad ass

 

Floyd didn't.

 

Fernando Vargas
Ricardo Mayorga
Shane Mosley

All fought Oscar while roided.

Who fought Mayweather while roided?

 

atsch Just stay in boxrec.

 

yeh back in 2005 were you been the past 7 years

floyd only fights winners

i'll take back my credit of floyd's wins then shall i because his opponents weren't on roids. atsch

i prefer staying over at your moms house :good

 

Hoya beat Tito more convincingly than Mayweather did Castillo in the rematch - having lost the first fight mind you.

 

I like Oscar better, and i feel he faced more top opponents

but Cmon man, floyd is just too good, too dominant, and too undefeated.