Who Ranks Higher Pernell Whitaker Or Floyd Mayweather Jr

Whitaker atm

 

whitaker but mayweather would have a competitive fight with him
now pac, whitaker would school that clown badly

 

wow, you managed to bring pac into a thread about floyd and whitaker. congrats.

 

Pea Whitaker as of right now but if PBF finishes his career 49-0 or 50-0 he will be ranked higher. PBF right now is a top 25 ATG Pea Whitaker top 15 ATG.

 

for me Floyd is already slightly higher.Floyd got longevity on his side,and still keeps going.
Whitaker top 15 ATG.floyd top 10.

 

Ridiculous. Nobody rates Floyd top 10 except the kids. Anyway I'd say it's close, with Whitaker having the edge at the moment, but it wouldn't surprise me if Floyd overtook Whitaker before his career ended.

 

floyd has this.

pea was done by 33, and he only moved up 4 weight classes. he doesn't have as amny championshp victories as floyd nor has he defeated more hofer's

floyd top 10 pea top 20 for me:deal

 

Floyd, Whitaker achieved great things but He could achieve more with a longer prime without drugs and problems.

 

bernard hopkins is ridicolous 48years old boy.rates floyd top 3..

can you please stop,it's my opinion and if someone is kid it's you and your opinion

only kids say i'm right you are wrong.opinions can i keep mine you can keep yours!

 

Whitaker based on their resumes at present, although with a solid end to his career Mayweather may rank higher due to his longevity and a greater quantity of world class wins.

Whitaker's career-defining "win" over Chavez is the most impressive thing on either man's record, and the wins over Nelson, Roger Mayweather, Haugen, Ramirez, McGirt and Vazquez stack up pretty well against most of Floyd's resume.

There is still plenty of room for Floyd to move up and down the ATG rankings, depending on what happens in his remaining fights.

 

Is this a joke Whitiker hands down .. No cherry picking for Sweat Pea !

 

PAC would ko pea in one round

Both are atg greats based on their résumé

Not floyd though

 

Pea.. Top somewhere between 25 and 20
Floyd between 40 and 35

 

:good ^This