Who rates higher Willie Pep or Sandy Saddler

I think they are a smidge ahead personally. He doesn't match them in resume imo.

 

Can't really see Pep and Saddler around #6 and #7.

No disrespect but many great scribes have poured over the division for hour after hour after hour and seldom if ever have Pep anywhere but 1 and Saddler is right up near the very top too. There's a reason said scribes are so consistent with this.

 

Go and scour any list by respectable identities including our very own ESB scribe. They are plentiful.