Who redeemed himself more?

Anyway, it's probably Ortiz.

 

Khan in my view. Maidana is a better fighter than Berto, Berto is one of those gap filling fighters who just happened to have a title.

I think Maidana would spank Ortiz again if they fought too.

 

I actually agree with this too.

Ortiz can't box on the outside like Khan (though he's slightly better mid range and a lot better inside), and he has a really leaky defence.

I think it'll turn into a slugfest like the first fight again after both of them get caught and hurt, and honestly in that situation I think it's Maidana's fight. That being said we don't know how Maidana will perform at 147.

 

Im a big fan of both...always have been....and even though i didnt think Ortiz deserved the flak he got for the Maidana fight....he redeemed himself big time with this fight....Khan was just out to prove the haters wrong....you cant question his heart....

 

Ortiz. Was make or break time for him really. People were writing him off already... 1 more loss and that's his career ****ed for the next few years. Instead he beats an undefeated champion at a higher weight and shows grit and heart (which people said he didn't have) to get off the canvas and win the fight pretty easily in the end.

Khan showed that he can take a decent shot. The general consensus was that if Maidana lands something big then it's game over, so fair play to him for showing that he's got heart and a better chin than he's given credit for. Didn't really redeem himself in the way that Ortiz did though, just shut a few doubters up.

 

To me, Khan proved his chin but proved that i had overrated his skills. I expected him to win by a comfortable TKO.
Ortiz showed so much improvement. He used to fade but this time he kept moving forward. Would love to see a few jabs tho.

 

Not if the rematch were to happen at 147, at least that's my opinion. :bbb

 

Ortiz would beat Maidana if they fought again. I think he underestimated Maidana last time out, thought he'd just blow through him. Ortiz is a better boxer, he'd strategise next time, not get into an all out war, outbox his man. Ortiz KO 8. It should happen eventually. Again.. Maidana is really, really overated.

 

Ortiz will quit again rather than taking a beating
Khan will get his glass jaw shattered again once he meets someone who halfway knows how to time a punch
so basically none
Ortiz slightly if at all

 

The Berto fight did for Ortiz what the Lennox Lewis fight did for Vitali. It did a 180 for his image. Ortiz showed heart, skill, and power in winning a very tough fight.