Who should really retire?

Everyone on that list except Winky and Hopkins. Chris Byrd, JL Castillo, I heard Morales is coming back which he shouldn't, Bowe, and Arce should call it quits.

 

Holyfield-he's 47? been fighting for a very long time 25 years, **** if he keeps going at this rate he won't live to be 60:-(
The obvious choice is Morrison, he's HIV+ SHOULDN'T EVEN BE IN THE RING..:verysad

 

holyfield should definitely retire but since he has arguably set himself up for another payday (with the "win" vs valuev), he should probably cash it in and just hope he doesn't suffer more damage in that last fight. Oscar should definitely retire because he ain't serious about being a 154 champ/contender and he's already rich as hell. Toney should retire b/c he's probably already brain damaged. Golota's borderline because he appeared to be definitely injured which played into his last bad loss and he's still decent enough to win some fights and is still marketable and he has probably always been brain damaged (just kidding a little). Hopkins and Winky probably have enough left and haven't taken enough beating where they need to be too worried. Judah is still young enough and could seriously make noise at 140, but should be stringently tested given some of the punishment he's taken. Jones Jr should probably retire, he's slipped, unlikely to really prove anything at this point and might have some lingering effects from the starchings around 2004.

 

Tua should fight on because he can K.o everyone and is dangerous

Austin is an bum unlike Tua he is chanceless against a beltholder same thing with fat Sinan Samil Sam.

Unlike Tua Golota was been ko'ed many times and is ****ing slow

Meehan should fight on because he is undefeated since 2004 has Ko'ed all his last opponents and deserves a last bigger payday

 

:goodfair enough though i disagree a bit. don't know if tua can put himself in position to ko "anybody" at this point afterall who has he ko'd in the past 5 years - ron guerro or somebody- but who knows? never thought much of meehan, but haven't seen him lately, but i don't know how he can be rated higher than the guys you mentioned.

 

Winky and Judah do not need to retire, however Zab is one ass whooping away from calling it a dubie.

 

hatton, after the pacquiao fight...

 

all of em except for Judah....