Who was better P4P: Roy Jones Jr or Floyd Mayweather Jr?

I am genuinely surprised someone could have thought Jones 'clearly' won that fight. He lay on the ropes for most of it and looked shattered, tried to flurry once or twice, never came to much. Tarver outworked and outfought him, a clear win. Don't suppose there's any point in continuing this, we disagree.

 

I think you know very very little about boxing. Age is just a number, it doesn't matter that Calzaghe is 35 or that Hopkins is 43, these guys have coped with age and are still regularly competing at the very top. Jones has not been doing so for years. It would be dangerous for his health to be allowed to follow a nonsense fight against a washed-up 147lbs fighter with a clash against a guy generally recognized in the boxing community as being one of the current best. To be considered worthy of a world title shot, don't opponents have to be fighting a certain level of opposition? Isn't that a rule? I don't think Jones should be allowed by the authorities to challenge Calzaghe. I fear for what would happen to him if he has had 4 years of deterioration since he was knocked spark out twice by two OK fighters.

 

I would bet everything I had that RJJ will not hear the final bell v Calzaghe. If they both fought in their prime, RJJ would wipe the floor with him. But the current RJJ who got KO'd by Glen Johnson and Antonio Tarver 3-4 years ago and has progressively deteriorated ever since with age would be destroyed by a guy still at the top of his game. It would be a walkover, a joke. Lewis v Tyson all over again (similar ages but 1 guy has coped far better with age than the other). I pray it doesn't happen as I don't want that to happen to RJJ. I wish boxing fans would ****ing smarten up and stop hyping old legends into fights they shouldn't be allowed to get into. I guess you're the sort of guy who hopes Erik Morales comes back or thinks Tito Trinidad could do a job v Hopkins. Your ignorance is dangerous.