Who was more athletic, Floyd Mayweather Jr. or Manny Pacquiao?

Pacquiao. Just an overall higher workrate.

Floyd is a very efficient fighter so it's no knock, he will slow the pace of a fight and use defence to nullify your workrate. He won't try and match it...he doesn't need to. Could he? maybe but that leaves room for error. Pacquiao is a like a crack demon.

Whether you like it or not Floyd waited out crack demon Pacquiao for post menopause Marquez planked Pacquiao with good reason...

 

you must be kidding.

pacquiao, and it's not even close. 1300-punches-pacman when he fought margarito was just mindblowing. Mayweather was NEVER EVER able to do something even remotely close to that.

 

Athleticism is one of the clearest 'Top Trump' categories where Pac is better than Mayweather IMO

 

Only a moron would equate punch volume with athleticism.

 

Probably even. With those Ariza shakes probably Pac tho.

 

Margarito threw 1675 vs Clottey. What person in their right mind would then say Margarito is more athletic than Pacquiao?

 

They were both exceptionally athletic in their primes. There isn't a way to definitively prove one was more athletic than the other. Both were deceptively strong or powerful, both had exceptional speed and agility, endurance. They each used the skills in different ways so I'd say it is generally a matter of preference.

 

First, in this fight you should, because as far as I know this is the WW record (I could be wrong, though, feel free to correct me if I am). Margarito was another athletic beast, I dont know why you deny that, tbh.

Second, margarito did it at WW, pacman did it a superWW. Sorry, but even if margo did a world record, it is not the same at WW as at SWW.

 

Both had legendary athleticism incl. perfect body control & energy levels over the championship rounds.

While Pacquiao's more obviously athletic for the untrained eye, Floyd micro-adjustments and inch-perfect hand, shoulder, foot and upper body control helped him with his defense and counters - talent alone doesn't make you go 50-0. Now one boxer that sparred with both said to me 15 yrs ago that Floyd's energy level is something else: he had several 15-minute sparring rounds and never stopped coming at you until 5-6 of his partners quit exhausted & bloody. This contradicts his boxer-first style in fights tho, but the source is very trustworthy.*

* the source is your mum if you are wondering

 

You calling Margarito an athletic beast proves you have no idea what athletic actually means.

 

obviously we dont agree in the definition of an athletic beast. Joyce is an athletic beast too, btw.

and mayweather is not. He's just an athletically good fighter, nothing too special. It's his ring IQ what's off the charts, not his athleticism. He always had an average workrate that helped him to keep his stamina and speed for 12 rounds, being able to handle the pace of the fight by pure ring IQ, imposing HIS workrate. Miniq described it very well in his post here, bth.

 

Pbf is. faster reflexes faster feet and better balance. Pac throwing with power or more punches a round doesn't make him a better athlete. Things like reflexes and hand eye coordination make people good athletes. When they fought it was clear pbf was the better athlete he was the faster fighter of both hand and foot.

 

Money faster reflexes more agile

 

No

This content is protected