Who was the best at their division?

Well your wrong on one aspect and that's mentioning Jones win over McCallum as a reason why he's a greater Super-Middleweight than Calzaghe. The McCallum fight was at Light-heavyweight.

Jones Jnr's title fight wins at 168: James Toney, Antonione Byrd,Tony Thonrton, Vinny Pazienza, Eric Lucas, Bryant Brannon.

Calzaghe's title wins at 168: Chris Eubank, Branko Sobot, Juan Carlos Ferreyra, Robin Reid, Rick Thornberry, David Starie, Omar Sheika, Richie Woodhall, Mario Veit(x2), Will McIntyre, Chales Brewer, Miguel Angel Jimenez, Tocker Pudwill, Byron Mitchell, Mger Mkrtchyan, Kabary Salem, Evans Ashira, Jeff Lacy, Sakio Bika, Peter Manfredo, Mikkel Kessler.

Now whatever your decision after that, the stupid thing is why you had to start this thread under false pretences. When you knew exactly what would happen and instead you could have just started your Roy Jones is a greater Super-Middleweight than Joe Calzaghe thread that you really wanted in the first place.

 

lol, Calzaghe beat the two guys you consider greats. While they were old, so was he and Bernard Hopkins showed he wasn't exactly shot when he decimated the current MW champion the fight after.

WW - It was never really dominated, it's been a passthrough weight for many fighters but I'd probably say Tito Trinidad for winning the biggest fight at WW - ODLH vs TT (even though ODLH should have won)

MW - B-Hop, easy.

SMW - Joe Calzaghe, easy, the most dominant of any of these fighters are one division, he beat everyone worth beating except Ottke due to Ottke not making the fight and cleared out "the new guard" three times in his career.

LHW - Jones Jr.

CW - No one comes to mind

HW - Wlad.

 

Hey PR. Love your avatar of your mama. She wants to say hello but she's got a mouth full right now, she'll call you later.

 

Bumping so that people can see how much of a dick mr PR is.

 

I agree with this except i put oscar at welter......no way mr. overrated, I hid under a rock most of my carear calzaghe gets on a greats list......