Who was the best British fighter in their prime out of this list?

joe beats them all hes not my fav but i think he licks the lot of them

 

JC but the Nigel Benn that beat Mclellon could beat anyone.

 

Agreed :good

 

Collins aint british

 

I think it's a trick question...

 

i was just a kid during benn/eubank days but remember itv fight night and the hype. loved it, start of my followin of boxing, altho i did lose it. anyway i remember watching and wanting eubank to lose every time. he just grated on me a bit like man u there good but you just want them to get stonked! despite this i picked eubank. i have no insightful opinion why, as was before more my time of dissecting fight s and fighters, but respect for the guy, great fighter greats showman

 

Would've loved to say Benn but can't justify it, probably has to be Calzaghe.

If the 2 were to have fought prime vs prime I know who my money would've been on though

 

Calzaghe. Then Watson. There's very little between them.

 

I can't help but feel that if it wasn't for that untimely tragedy, Micahael Watson would have gone on to much bigger things. He had already beaten Benn and was very possibly winning the second Eubank fight, before that vicious uppercut.

I want to say Benn as he's my fav but Calzaghe beats them all I think.

 

id love to say nigel benn,but 3 of them beat him.
eubank and watson when benn was just a reckless monster,and really punched himself out then got stopped,and collins when benn was past his best,taking nowt away from collins though.
i think prime boxing, moving benn (not the early animal)would giv JC a few scares,could spark him if he catchs him on the button,but prob JC on points

collins was a tough ****er who would wear you down,but he wouldent have enough to beat JC

 

Benn was just an absolute beast.

 

The Eubank that beat Benn was very good, but calzaghe is possibly the best on that list.

1. Calzaghe
2. Eubank
3. Benn/Watson
5. Collins

 

I picked Benn, but that is unashamedly a fan vote