Who was the better South African Heavyweight, Gerrie Coatzee or Frans Botha?

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by tommy the hat, Sep 5, 2008.


  1. tommy the hat

    tommy the hat Active Member Full Member

    1,151
    9
    Sep 2, 2008
    So who would you take, the Bionic Man or the White Buffalo?
     
  2. Polymath

    Polymath Boxing Junkie Full Member

    8,651
    3
    Sep 29, 2007
  3. tommy the hat

    tommy the hat Active Member Full Member

    1,151
    9
    Sep 2, 2008
    Yea I thought about throwing Corrie in there but thought Botha and Coatzee were more similiar
     
  4. SuperSouthpaw

    SuperSouthpaw Member Full Member

    152
    0
    Sep 5, 2008
    I like Gerrie Coetzee by knockout. But if these 2 had to face Corrie Sanders, Sanders takes them both in 1-2 rounds! Corrie was way too much for them to handle.
     
  5. zadfrak

    zadfrak Boxing Junkie Full Member

    8,418
    2,950
    Feb 17, 2008
    Botha, by far, was the most beatable of the group. And that's also the reason he was provided more top 10 opportunities than the other guys--because he was so beatable & the other guy can come out with the win. If you had a top notch fighter, all you needed to do was get them in good condition & Botha becomes an excellent opponent.

    Sanders and Coetzee both had A+ results in big bouts outside of South Afriica with the Klitschko & Spinks scalps. Botha never had that A+ result against top competiton.
     
  6. he grant

    he grant Historian/Film Maker

    25,082
    8,831
    Jul 15, 2008
    Coetzee beats the Buffalo ... Sanders was a huge under achiever ... he could have been a near great but really did not love the game ... never fully dedicated himself ... a waste ...
     
  7. ChrisPontius

    ChrisPontius March 8th, 1971 Full Member

    19,404
    275
    Oct 4, 2005
    Coetzee, i'd say. His right hand was really powerful and during a period of time, he was a legitimate challenger to Holmes' world title. Botha, on the other, was a hard-working, decent all-round contender, but not really a big threat and lost most of the times he fought a top level fighter. He did draw with Briggs if memory serves me right.

    Contrary to Coetzee, he did get his title shot against Lennox Lewis, but was blown out in spectacular fashion, two rounds. He was on the end of two of the best knockouts of the 90's against two of the best heavyweights, which will probably see to it that he is longer remembered than Coetzee. The one thing Francois had over Gerrie was management, a very important factor.
     
  8. DamonD

    DamonD Boxing Junkie Full Member

    14,285
    38
    Nov 19, 2004
    I'd go with Coetzee, a more dangerous fighter.

    Botha was durable and crafty, and fought with a lot of heart, but wasn't offensively in the same class.

    Corrie Sanders, of course, beats them both at the same time with one flick of his muscular eyebrow.
     
  9. Bummy Davis

    Bummy Davis Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    23,642
    2,111
    Aug 26, 2004

    I would have to agree, Coetzee had poor management and when he finally got Jackie McCoy as a trainer, it was like teaching an old dog new tricks, still Gerrie had a powerfull right hand and had an impressive 1 rd blowout over Leon Spinks and Michael Dokes and was robbed vs Renaldo Snipes when he had Snipes down 2 times in their fight and Snipes got the Nod...Coetzee had nothing to do with the politics of his country but was penilized because of it. Sanders was also avoided but did not always show the best motorvation. Funny but the Whites were a minority in Africa but yet dominated Heavyweight boxing there
     
  10. r_9-Ronaldo

    r_9-Ronaldo Shinny Shadez Full Member

    1,569
    0
    Jul 27, 2008
    I always though Botha was North African? aint he maruitaus
     
  11. Vantage_West

    Vantage_West ヒップホップ·プロデューサー Full Member

    20,749
    520
    Jul 11, 2006
    coetzee. he had beaten many world class fighters where as botha scraped passed at that level.
    coetzee had more tools than botha and used them well.... also he had a upset ranking. his ko of spinks was a big surprise to some. he has much more than just a right hand that his name conjures up
    (somone has uploaded his back catalogue on youtube)





    but respect to botha. ive got to say im always always impressed how far he got with just a right hand and a slight jab.

    his tactics against tyson were superb. stay away on the outside with a jab, when he comes in throw a right uppercut and clinch. when you break up bop aroudn the ring and taunt him with a light jab and repeat.


    an overachiever but a good overachiever
     
  12. Vantage_West

    Vantage_West ヒップホップ·プロデューサー Full Member

    20,749
    520
    Jul 11, 2006
    [YT]HCru5VYWwqA[/YT]






    [YT]HhqzvFKTozA[/YT]

    [YT]jXfE14KiETs[/YT]

    [YT]y0zPLBYK2Yk[/YT]
     
  13. TBooze

    TBooze Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    25,495
    2,145
    Oct 22, 2006
    Coetzee at his best would be far too much for either Botha or Sanders, indeed I would place the hard working Pierre Coetzer above Sanders and Botha.

    I never saw what people see in Sanders, if you want a South Africa Heavyweight engima, then I would put foward Jimmy Abbott.
     
  14. fists of fury

    fists of fury Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    19,297
    7,039
    Oct 25, 2006
    Excellent point.

    Botha, pardon the pun, punched above his weight. He was marginally talented but nobody here expected much from him. Where he was smart was that he moved to the States early in his career and benefitted from better training, better sparring and got exposure.

    Had Coetzee gone to the States much earlier in his career, he could have achieved more. Same with Sanders really. Instead, both Coetzee and Sanders chose to remain big fish in a small pond, and did not make the most of their raw ability.

    Honestly, I'd also put Pierre Coetzer and maybe Johnny Du Plooy over Botha as well. Both had their limitations, but for one Coetzer was a tough son of a ***** who showed up in superb shape for his fights (which goes against the grain when discussing SA heavyweights normally) and Du Plooy had flair and a good punch.
     
  15. fists of fury

    fists of fury Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    19,297
    7,039
    Oct 25, 2006
    The reason is that that blacks here just aren't big. The average black guy in this country are slightly smaller than the average westerner, unlike say the Nigerians who produce large, strong black fighters.
    On the contrary, the whites, particularly those of Dutch heritage, are above average in size.
    The Afrikaaners are quite large on average, and it's not uncommon to see an Afrikaaner over six feet and 220 lbs.