Who Was The Hardest Puncher Marciano Met?

Okay, but he wasn't the one who mentioned Robert Bellarmine.

 

As I was the one who mentioned Bellarmine, I assumed you were replying to me.

My mistake.

 

Anyway, things like fan, or fanboy, or nutlicker, as arguing statements are merely logical fallacies, technically called ad hominem circumstancials--arguing that because someone has a point of view, his point of view is illegitimate.

But that isn't true. Native Americans probably have a point of view that they were driven off their land and treaties they made with the government were broken.

That they are looking at it from their own point of view doesn't mean their arguments are wrong.

Actually, everyone has a point of view and so such insults are meaningless.

 

I don't, now that you explained it.

 

:good Great Job

 

Bingo!

Sometimes you are just not allowed to elaborate...

Raw power gets the job done. Technique and timing gets the job done. Both types are effective.

That Robinson is rated so highly as a puncher proves it.

 

I'm not trying to enhance anyones punching ability to make Marciano look better here, I just want some questions answered.

Did Robinson have raw power? Yes or no? Was Robinson an effective knockout puncher?

Did Charles have raw power? Yes or no? Was Charles an effective knockout puncher?

Does a puncher have to have "Raw power" to be considered an effective puncher?

Is a severe puncher an effective puncher?

 

atsch

Nice try but Baksi was only 26 years old. :nut

Baksi had something like a 32 lb weight advantage and there are no reports of him ever being down or getting tore up this bad. Charles was the only man to stop him in his 73 fight career.

Charles according to this report put a severe beating on him. Baksi apparently tried to quit in the 10th but the ref stopped it in the 11th. I think Charles outslugging a 32 lb heavier contender for his only career stoppage goes well for him as a P4P puncher.

[url]http://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=888&dat=19481221&id=S_hOAAAAIBAJ&sjid=IU4DAAAAIBAJ&pg=2051,229643[/url]

 

It alone doesn't qualify but like I said.."it goes well for." Being the only man to stop the tough Baksi in his long career while at a 32 lb disadvantage is quite a punching achievement. Nobody tore Baksi up like that, his nose and mouth was also bleeding profusely, and he was described as being "trounced" and "tiring" at the stoppage.

I posted a more detailed article. The ref refused to stop it when Baksi asked.

I'm not surprised by that omission. I believe Charles' punching ability is criminaly underrated.