pernell could barely move at 154...which is what weight im guessing the fight is gonna be at. vargas might be slower and hitable but he used his size pressure to great effect. he would catch pernell a few times and possibly drop him....think of it like whitaker vs hurtardo. lets also take into account that varquez was a mean mutha but was an awful technician. and was schooled. pernell went back down in weight for th every reason that he couldnt school him enough. vargas by ud. in a bit of a dog fight.
I voted Vargas because Ive only ever seen Whitaker up at 154 once & tho he won a close fight vs Vasquez, he looked dire compared to his previous fight (the Mcgirt rematch at 147)... 154 is not for Pea, the weight basically robbed him of his mobility & Vargas aint fighting any lower than 154. P4P - Pernell leaves him for dead. H2H - Too much of an ask, Vargas wins.
But the thread title says `who wins between the aztech warrior & sweetness` :huh Do you really have to ask who was better p4p between Whitaker & Vargas ?