Well you obviously don't know much about Eubank if you think his chin was anything less than granite!!!
Winner prime Eubank, second Hopkins, third Benn Pavlik, Mclellan, Nunn would have the 4 - 6 (in no special order) Regarding Eubank's chin: It was very solid to say the least. Prime Eubank also had very good reactions and a good timing which often helped him to avoid getting hit.