I have it like this too but when I think "winning" the rivalry, there's only one image that comes to mind
Anyone who says it's clear is wrong. 1 and 2 were difficult to score. 3 and 4 were Marquez. They're anything from 2-2 to 0-4 and everything in between. I think the lack of consistency shows that they need a 5th fight, but it won't ever happen.
JMM. The fact Pacman fought him a 4th time says it all. JMM won the 3rd clearly, the 4th brutally and for me won the 1st fight.
I believe it's crucial that this thread had to be made. We're nearing the 1 year anniversary of the superfight.