sure Ali is hard to beat what about Chuvalo ? Ali Foreman Frazier Ellis Quarry Mathis Bonavena Terrell Patterson Jones Folley
If Benny Leonard didn't sucker punch Jack Britton the result likely would have been Leonard KO 13, and the welterweight championship. Ad that win to the rest of his resume. It would be very hard to beat. There is also his last fight with McLarnin that he lost. Someone who could beat it is Ray Leonard. Had he won the decision over Duran in their first fight. Beaten Hearns in their second fight. Than Noris and Camacho. I think the gaps between 82-84 and 84-87 hurt Ray Leonard's resume status.
Cotto's would be mint. Pacquaio, Mayweather, Mosley, Judah, Margarito, blah blah blah Oscars would be good too.
Ezzard Charles 3x, Muhammad Ali, Charley Burley, Rocky Marciano, Jimmy Bivins 5x, Harold Johnson 5x, Holman Williams 2x, Lloyd Marshall 2x, Eddie Booker 3x, Floyd Patterson, Joey Maxim 3x, Jack Chase 5x, Bert Lytell 2x, Cocoa Kid, Bobo Olsen, Aaron Wade, Willie Pastrano, Nino Valdez, Shorty Hogue 3x, Oakland Billy Smith 2x, Curtis Sheppard, Clarence Henry, Yvon Durelle 2x, etc. :deal
Under this criteria Jake LaMotta would have six wins over Sugar Ray Robinson, wouldn't he? Beating the GOAT six times basically trumps everyone else I would say.
Archie Moore. Ezzard Charles 3x, Muhammad Ali, Charley Burley, Rocky Marciano, Jimmy Bivins 5x, Harold Johnson 5x, Holman Williams 2x, Lloyd Marshall 2x, Eddie Booker 3x, Floyd Patterson, Joey Maxim 3x, Jack Chase 5x, Bert Lytell 2x, Cocoa Kid, Bobo Olsen, Aaron Wade, Willie Pastrano, Nino Valdez, Shorty Hogue 3x, Oakland Billy Smith 2x, Curtis Sheppard, Clarence Henry, Yvon Durelle 2x, etc. If not him, then my 2nd choice would be... Archie Moore. Ezzard Charles 3x, Muhammad Ali, Charley Burley, Rocky Marciano, Jimmy Bivins 5x, Harold Johnson 5x, Holman Williams 2x, Lloyd Marshall 2x, Eddie Booker 3x, Floyd Patterson, Joey Maxim 3x, Jack Chase 5x, Bert Lytell 2x, Cocoa Kid, Bobo Olsen, Aaron Wade, Willie Pastrano, Nino Valdez, Shorty Hogue 3x, Oakland Billy Smith 2x, Curtis Sheppard, Clarence Henry, Yvon Durelle 2x, etc. :deal