Who would of won at 160 Hopkins vs. Toney

Would've probably ended in a draw.

 

Hopkins UD...

 

I'd go for Hopkins just. I doubt it would have been an exciting fight.

 

Hmmm. Hopkins just about. Toney would beat him above 160.

 

hard to say but i feel toney by KO or B-Hop bye decision

 

Yea the dude in your sidebar had a tougher fight with Hops than he did with Toney..

 

Hopkins by clear Decision.

 

Hopkins UD

I feel his footwork, movement, and variety of angles would have frusturated Toney.

 

Close Hopkins victory at MW, SMW, LHW. As Manny Steward said, Hopkins was always a natural LHW. He proved that at 40+ and at LHW Toney had troubles even with Griffin.

In the highter classes I wouldn't choose a winner as CW and HW is too much for Hopkins and at those weight classes Toney's steroid use probably made a very important effect. Said thing to write that down but you just can't rule that out.

 

hopkins ud in a very borin fight

 

I'd go with Toney at middleweight...his speed and defensive abilities would of landed him a UD no matter how much Hopkins tried to hold and headbutt.

 

Hopkins outworks Toney for a clear UD.

 

Toney at middleweight was horribly inconsistent.

he should've lost to tiberi and the mccallum rematch. the johnson fight could have gone either way too.

he improved once he left 160. experience, and more comfort at the weight.

hopkins ud toney

 

I didn't like Toney at 160, at that weight Hopkins would win

I'd take Toney at the higher weights