Who would of won if they fought, Froch or Calzaghe?

I know mate, I was responding to Aussie who was ducking the question

SMW was very strong then. I would favour (going a bit later than the time you mentioned) Lacy to beat many of the current fighters at the weight today. He had a better resume than many today in the division with wins over Pemberton, Tsypko, Sheika, Vanderpool and Reid

 

Eubank at that time had the best SMW resume ever at that point, far greater than anyone else who had fought in the division at that time

 

He hadn't cut ties when he agreed to go to America and face Hopkins when they tried to make the fight years ago. He also hadn't cut ties when he did go to America and beat Hopkins, so you have no point or clue.
Also what are you on about... Calzaghe beat Hopkins arguably sandwiched between his best wins of Tarver, Wright and Pavlik
Hopkins was the champ at LHW and Calzaghe was closer to the end of his career

 

Good fight. Gotta go with Joe's speed and workrate to win a decision.