Who would win between Archie Moore or James Bonecrusher Smith?

Smith lost to marvis Frazier, axel Schulz, Tubbs, page, you name em, they beat him! He was a pretty big heavy dude and had a good chin so it likely goes the distance but he has no way of actually getting the verdict. Outside of a punchers chance, this would be a pretty convincing win Moore often than not.

 

I agree, but how old was he when Shultz beat him?

 

Moore easily

 

Bonecrusher was big and strong but he was being out boxed easily by Bruno before stoppage.
Mongoose levels above Bruno skill. Mongoose pts.

 

Moore by UD 10-15

 

This. Bonecrusher is too slow and would get picked apart and stopped by Moore.

 

This is difficult, Smith was doing okay against an ageing Holmes who was bigger than Archie. On the strength of his wins over Baker and Valdes,I pick Moore by decision.

 

Smith in his best days had a good chin. If anyone gets stopped here it would be Moore but I can see him getting a decision over Smith though it wouldn’t surprise me if he gets caught by Smith either.

 

THERES always a chance of a lucky punch landing

 

I think Smith has a marginally better chance of exhausting and sparking out Moore than Moore has of decisioning him. Marginally.