I think this would be a good fight. I think Paulie would win because of his speed advantage, his style, and his youth. I think if Joel can't get a fight with Juan Diaz he should move up to 140. If Joel does move up I would like to see him fight Paulie.
Im going w/ the Magic man .. he won't have the power to KO the cuban vet .. but in this stage of their careers he would walk circles around Joel.. Im thinking Joel would lose a couple points on dirty tactics if the fight happens in NY.
Paullie by decission. :yep Casa is too slow and too old for Paullie at this point . . . Paullie is the kind of fighter who never stops in one place. Plus I would assume they'll be fighting at 140. Well Paullie is a natural 140 lber.